Pemimpin ultra kiasu yang pernah ‘menyerang’ saya suatu ketika dahulu mengenai perdebatan anak luar nikah, masih tidak mahu menerima hakikat bahawa sekolah vernakular adalah antara punca kepada kemerosotan atau kelemahan tahap penguasaan bahasa kebangsaan kalangan pelajar bukan Melayu. Lebih berat lagi katanya, bahasa bukanlah punca polarisasi antara hari ini. Puncanya adalah datang daripada ketidakadilan dasar Umno (Barisan Nasional) yang memerintah kerajaan. Pendek kata, pada mereka aspek bahasa dan sekolah perkauman bukanlah penyumbang utama.
Beliau mempertikaikan kajian yang dibuat oleh Kesatuan Perkhidmatan Perguruan Kebangsaan (KPPK) baharu-baharu ini. Cadangan saya, kalau kita menolak sesuatu fakta, maka kemukakan fakta baharu atau buat kajian baharu untuk membidas kajian terdahulu. Ini tidak, cakap seperti orang tidak sekolah. Elok juga kerajaan pimpinan Pakatan Rakyat melakukan kajian yang serupa, jika tidak yakin dengan kajian sebelum ini. Jangan terlalu menyalahkan orang lain.
Menyalahkan kerajaan Umno (BN) dan sistem pendidikan menengah kebangsaan yang didakwa gagal memandaikan anak bangsanya menguasai bahasa negara ini tidak akan menyelesaikan masalah. Ultra kiasu tetap ultra kiasu. Adakah beliau tidak sedar bahawa beliau juga produk sekolah menengah kebangsaan. Jika dari kecil beliau mendapat pendidikan sekolah rendah Cina, kemudian belajar di sekolah menengah Cina, masuk universiti Cina, saya yakin, beliau tidak akan mampu bercakap bahasa Melayu seperti adanya sekarang.
Ultra kiasu ini turut menyalahkan pengajaran dan pembelajaran (P&P) di sekolah rendah dan menengah tidak membolehkan pelajar-pelajar vernakular menguasai bahasa kebangsaan. Sudah tentu dalam hal ini mereka merujuk kepada guru Melayu yang mengajar bahasa Melayu. Jika begitulah keadaannya, saya cadangkan kita biarlah guru Cina mengajar bahasa Melayu. Kita mahu lihat, berjaya atau tidak mereka memandaikan anak bangsanya.
Fakta perlu diiringi dengan penyelidikan (R&D). Paling tidakpun, pergilah buat tinjauan di sekolah vernakular. Uji kebolehan berbahasa mereka. Sila anjurkan pertandingan pidato atau bercerita. Biar kita pakat-pakat dengar bagaimana pelajar sekolah ini berhujah dalam bahasa Melayu. Jangan terlalu menegakkan benang basah.
Berapa ramai ahli politik dan ahli perniagaan Cina apabila disoal dalam bahasa Melayu, terus tiba-tiba beralih kepada bahasa Inggeris atau bahasa ibunda. Jelas-jelas menunjukkan bahawa mereka tidak boleh berbahasa kebangsaan. Sebenarnya, jika dibanci ramai ahli-ahli parti ultra kiasu yang tidak boleh berbahasa Melayu dengan baik. Bagi mereka agenda nasional tidak penting, yang penting agenda bangsa.
Ultra kiasu berhujah lagi, apa guna menguasai dan lulus bahasa Melayu, jika akhirnya nanti mereka tidak dapat masuk dalam sektor perkhidmatan awam yang rata-rata dibolot oleh Melayu (80 peratus)? Justeru, orang Cina terpaksa menumpukan bahasa yang mempunyai nilai komersial seperti Inggeris dan ibunda. Ultra kiasu sengaja memejam mata bahawa produk sekolah vernakular turut lemah dalam Inggeris. Mereka sengaja tidak mahu membuat kajian kenapa orang Cina tidak berminat menyertai sektor perkhidmatan awam dan berapa ramai telah dilantik memegang jawatan tinggi, tetapi asyik menuding jari kepada kerajaan.
Bagi mereka yang cerdik dan membuat kajian, sosialisasi seseorang itu yang menentukan kemahiran berbahasa dan tahap perpaduan kaum. Jika sosialisasinya perkauman, maka perkaumanlah jawapannya. Parti ultra kiasu janganlah nak menunjuk hebat, cubalah bertanding di kawasan majoriti Melayu dan berkempenlah dalam bahasa Melayu, kita mahu lihat, sejauhmana ahli-ahlinya boleh pergi jauh dengan bahasa kebangsaan ini.
Bagaimana pelajar sekolah vernakular boleh menguasai bahasa Melayu jika hanya diajar tiga kali seminggu, yakni lebih kurang 2 jam seminggu. Kerajaan cuba menambah masa P&P bahasa Melayu di sekolah vernakular tetapi ditolak mentah-mentah oleh Dong Jiao Zong. Hujah mereka mudah, melebihkan bahasa Melayu akan menjejaskan penguasaan bahasa Mandarin. Hari ini mereka menuntut supaya diberikan layanan samarata dan sama rasa, tetapi kurikulum langsung tidak boleh disentuh, apatah lagi mahu menyerahkan bangunan, tanah dan pentadbiran sekolah.
Keadaan akan menjadi lebih gawat lagi apabila baharu-baharu ini Presiden MCA mengumumkan bahawa MCA akan menandatangani Memorandum of Cooperation (MoC) dengan 7 universiti Taiwan melalui Universiti Tunku Abdul Rahman (UTAR), Kolej Tunku Abdul Rahman (KTAR) and Koperasi Jaya Diri (Kojadi). Universiti tersebur adalah The Chinese Culture University, Feng Chia University, MingDao University, TransWorld University, I-Shou Univesity, the National Taipei University of Technology, and the National Taiwan University of Science and Technology. Menurut presiden ultra kiasu itu, perkara ini perlu dilakukan kerana hanya 1peratus peratus sahaja pelajar-pelajar Cina daripada keseluruhan 86,000 pelajar-pelajar vokasional di negara ini.
Persoalannya, adakah angka ini benar? Jika benar, adakah bilangan yang sedikit ini disebabkan oleh dasar kerajaan atau memang orang Cina itu sendiri tidak mahu memasuki vokasional tempatan, maka peluang ini digunakan sepenuhnya untuk mencinakan lagi orang Cina dengan menghantar mereka ke Negara China. Kenapa perlu ke Taiwan? Tidak ada negeri lain lagikah untuk dikunjungi? Pergilah ke negeri berdekatan, untuk menjimatkan belanja seperti Thailand yang tidak kurang membangunnya atau sekurang-kurangnya ke Korea Selatan. Hebatkan sangatkah Taiwan dalam bidang vokasional? Sebelum ini saya telah sebut, lebih baik pelajar Cina didedahkan dengan persekitaran di luar lingkungan bangsanya, barulah tidak menjadi ultra kiasu.
Alasan kedua katanya adalah selari dengan Progran Transformasi Ekonomi (ETP) di bawah kepimpinan Perdana Menteri untuk melahirkan lebih ramai pekerja berkemahiran. Dalam jangka masa 10 tahun, negara memerlukan 30 juta peluang pekerjaan, 40 peratus daripadanya adalah pekerja mahir. Ditanya sama ada sijil tersebut akan diiktiraf oleh kerajaan atau tidak, senang sahaja jawapan presiden ultra kiasu ini, itu kerja MCA untuk memastikan ia diiktiraf berdasarkan kejayaan beliau mendesak kerajaan mengiktiraf beberapa universiti di China.
Persoalan saya, adakah dengan berada di negara China, mereka akan mempunyai jati diri Malaysia yang kukuh. Apakah agenda mereka di sebalik semua ini, kalau bukan untuk melahirkan lebih ramai lagi ultra kiasu bagi memperkasa agenda bangsa berbanding agenda nasional? Kita amat bimbang jika agenda bangsa terlalu banyak ditonjolkan polarisasi akan semakin meluas, walaupun gagasan 1Malaysia itu yang dijadikan hujah utama dalam mewujudkan perpaduan antara kaum.
Terbaharu, Presiden Parti Bersatu Rakyat Sabah (PBRS) mencadangkan penubuhan Kolej Kadazan Dusun dan Murut atau Kolej KDM di Sabah. Satu lagi agenda bangsa. Tidak lama lagi selepas itu, tidak mustahil setiap parti komponen BN berasaskan etnik, akan menyuarakan perkara yang sama atas alasan “untuk menjaga bangsanya dalam mencapai matlamat gagasan 1Malaysia”.
Bayang di negara kita mempunyai lebih daripada 50 jenis etnik. Jika setiap etnik, mahukan institusi pengajian sendiri, apa akan jadi dengan sistem pendidikan Malaysia pada masa akan datang? Tidak perlu ditanya kepada setiap etnik untuk mendapatkan persetujuan, kerana sudah pasti mereka akan bersetuju. Inilah akibatnya apabila kita membenarkan universiti berasaskan kaum dan parti-parti politik perkauman beroperasi. Sepatutnya perlembagaanlah yang menjadi terma rujukan dalam melakukan apa jua perkara, terutama soal pendidikan nasional, yang menjadi tunggak pembinaan negara bangsa. Ini tidak, dalam kepala kita hanya ada agenda bangsa.
Seperti ultra kiasu yang lain, alasan penubuhan kolej tersebut adalah untuk memajukan masyarakat kaum itu, bersama kaum lain, di bawah konsep 1Malaysia dan juga membawa semangat mengukuhkan perpaduan, supaya tidak ada kaum yang akan merasa terpinggir. Sekali lagi gagasan 1Malaysia menjadi batu galasannya. Malangnya sungguh gagasan ini, dipergunakan untuk mendapatkan sama rata dan sama rasa, bukannya untuk mendapatkan keadilan, kerana makna keadilan itu meletakkan sesuatu pada tempatnya.
Ditakdirkan nanti, jika diluluskan kolej ini, kaum Iban, Melanau, Dayak dan sebagainya di Sarawak akan meminta diwujudkan kolej atau universiti yang sama. Bayangkan selepas ini, jika orang Asli mendesak kerajaan menubuhkan universiti orang Asli. Sudah tentu pening kepala kita dibuatnya, sebab dari segi hak, mereka lebih berhak. Selepas itu, diikuti minoriti Siam di Perlis, Kedah dan Kelantan bersatu menuntut kerajaan menubuhkan Universiti Siam atas alasan 1Malaysia! Tidakkah haru-biru sistem pendidikan negara kita?
Kewujudan kolej atau universiti hendaklah berdasarkan kepada keperluan bukannya tuntutan. Lambakan universiti berdasarkan tuntutan hanya akan menjejaskan kualiti pendidikan. Cukuplah dengan Institusi Pengajian Tinggi Awam (IPTA) yang sedia ada. Sama-samalah kita memperkasa dan memperkuatkannya.
Perlu diingat, semua ini bermula apabila kita meluluskan universiti yang dipunyai oleh MCA, Gerakan, MIC dan NGO-NGO perkauman yang ada. Akibatnya, sudah tentu ada bangsa merasa terpinggir, apatah mereka adalah bumiputera yang sepatunya mempunyai lebih hak. Sedangkan yang lain, bukan bumiputera, bukan sahaja mendapat universiti sendiri malahan idea universiti merdeka telah pun menjadi realiti.
Fahamkah kita apakah maksud universiti itu sebenarnya? Di luar negara, tidak ada universiti berasaskan etnik. Jika adapun adalah ‘kerusi’ atau pusat kajian etnik tertentu. Cuma di negara kita amat pelik dan memelikkan, kenapa universiti berasaskan etnik atau parti politik diwujudkan? Saya cadangkan supaya ‘kerusi’ atau pusat kajian etnik-etnik diwujudkan di IPTA dan Institusi Pengajian Tinggi Swasta (IPTS) yang sediakan ada, daripada mewujudkan kolej atau universiti khusus untuk kaum tertentu. Dalam pada itu, masih belum terlambat untuk mengambilalih dan menyerapkan universiti berasaskan parti politik atau NGO perkauman ke dalam pendidikan nasional.
Saya merayu kepada bumiputera Sabah dan Sarawak, janganlah bertindak seperti parti ultra kiasu. Perkauman ultra kiasu hanya akan meruntuhkan negara. Kerajaan pula janganlah terlalu melayan tuntutan ini. Jika beginilah keadaannya, IPTA yang lain akan terjejas teruk pada masa akan datang kerana tidak dapat bersaing dengan IPTS yang sudah tentu lebih gagah dari segi kewangannya dan mendapat sokongan serta dokongan rangkaian antarabangsa.
Setiap kaum akan bermati-matian membantu dan mempertahankan universiti bangsa mereka sendiri. Saya yakin, sudah pasti kekuatan ultra kiasu jauh melebihi kekuatan kerajaan kerana kekuatan kewangan mereka lebih besar. Apatah lagi jika derma mereka di universiti ultra kiasu dikecualikan atau boleh ditolak daripada cukai pendapatan. Universiti mereka sudah menjadi kaya raya.
Saya amat yakin, sebahagian besar cukai-cukai telahpun dialirkan ke sana dan akan dialirkan seterusnya. Ini sudah pasti akan meninggalkan kesan terhadap pendapatan negara. Akhirnya, siapa yang akan rugi? Kedudukan IPTA sudah tentu akan terjejas. Peruntukannya terhad dan perlu dikongsi dengan IPTA yang lain. Berbanding dengan universiti perkauman mereka terus mendapat dana demi dana. Lebih beruntung lagi, kadang kala tanah dan beberapa prasarana lain diberikan secara percuma oleh kerajaan. Tidak perlulah saya sebut nama universiti ultra kiasu tersebut.
Selain itu, masa depan bahasa Melayu sebagai bahasa kebangsaan akan menjadi semakin suram. Maklum sahajalah, pada mereka bahasa Melayu tidak ada nilai komersial. Buat setakat ini hanya subjek teras sahaja yang diajar dalam bahasa Melayu seperti Kenegaraan Malaysia dan Hubungan Etnik, selebih semuanya diajar dalam bahasa Inggeris dan bahasa ibunda. Ke manakah arah tuju pendidikan negara kita menjelang 2020 nanti? Apakah kita akan berjaya membina sebuah negara bangsa dan masyarakat idaman?
181 comments:
Di telan mati emak, diluah mati bapa - begitulah celarunya rakyat majmuk Malaysia yang kini berpolitik setiap hari.
Politk mesti berpolitik setiap hari. Di mana mana pun dalam dunia. Dinegara kominis pun.
Mari kita sokong apa yang betul atau bangkang apa yang tak betul yang RT cakap. Kita sebutkan setuju atau tak setuju.
Saya sokong banyak yang RT cakap itu. Akan masuk sini lagi bila lapang.
Salam.
Beberapa ketika dulu saya berkesempatan melawat sebuah bandar di Sumut, Medan.
Saya perhatikan dan agak terkejut tidak ada kedai keturunan Cina di sebuah bandar sebesar itu.
Setelah berpeluang mengunjungi secara dekat, rupa-rupanya ramai peniaga Cina di sana, cuma (saya tak pasti sekarang masih serupa)tidak terdapat "tulisan Cina" dikedai-kedai berkenaan. Raut wajah masih boleh dikenali keturunannya, cuma mereka lebih suka berbicara dalam bahasa Indonesia.Nama-nama kedai juga nampaknya dalam bahasa Indonesia. Boleh, kalau mahu !
Poster-poster filem Cina di pawagam ada yang ditutup tulisan Cinanya.
Itu saya lihat kira-kira 20 tahun dulu.Sekarang mungkin dah berubah.
Kalau kita melancong ke negara di utara tanahair, kita akan lihat wajah-wajah Cina, tetapi hanya mau bercakap dalam bahasa Thai.
Kenapa, di Malaysia tak boleh ?
Salam Dr
Saya sangat setuju dengan artikel kali ini.
Dimana kiblat mereka (Cina ultrakiasu)? Jawapannya tidak lain dan tidak bukan; Negara Komunis Cina. Lihat sahaja pada isu bahasa; pada persoalan apakah yang sepatutnya diambil sebagai bahasa perpaduan Cina Malaysia? Mereka tidak rujuk pada bahasa kebangsaan Malaysia tetapi sebaliknya merujuk kepada Negara Cina dan mengambil Bahasa Kebangsaan Cina (Mandarin) sebagai bahasa perpaduan mereka. Apa salahnya jika mereka ambil bahasa kebangsaan Malaysia sebagai bahasa yang boleh menyatukan mereka yang mempunyai bahasa ibunda yang pelbagai? Kenapa mesti Mandarin? Kenapa tidak Bahasa Melayu? Malah faedahnya lebih besar lagi, bukan sahaja kaum Cina Malaysia boleh bersatu malah Kaum Cina dan Melayu boleh bersatu diatas satu bahasa.
Berkenaan dengan alasan BM tidak komersial dan sebagainya. Inilah bezanya orang yang patriotik dan yang tidak patriotik. Sekiranya patriotisme dan sayang pada negara itu ada pada mereka, maka tidak timbul isu komersial atau tidak! Kita mendaulatkan bahasa kebangsaan tanpa sebarang alasan dan bukan kerana nilai komersialnya tetapi semata mata kerana kita sayang pada Negara.
Dan lagi berkenaan dengan soal komersial, salah siapakah ini? Saya cukup hairan bagaimana seorang manusia peniaga boleh berada di Malaysia, menjalankan perniagaan atau bekerja di Malaysia, boleh menyatakan yang BM tidak ada nilai komersial!. Saya yakin 80% sektor komersial di Malaysia ada hubung kait secara langsung atau tidak langsung samaada dengan kerajaan atau pengguna di Malaysia sendiri yang mana majoriti di kedua dua bidang ini adalah orang Melayu yang bertutur bahasa Melayu. Saya ambil contoh sektor pembinaan. Sektor ini memberi servis kepada kerajaan, orang perseorangan atau swasta . Kerajaan, sudah tentunya majoriti Melayu, manakala pihak swasta yang mereka bekerja pula kebanyakannya memberi servis kepada kerajaan atau pengguna yang juga kebanyakan Melayu. Ditambah pula dengan segala proses undang undang dan kelulusan import / eksport / kelulusan pembangunan yang memerlukan mereka berurusan dengan kerajaan yang juga majoritinya Melayu. Jadi bagaimana pula bahasa melayu boleh tiada nilai komersial!!??. Amatlah pelik?
Terus terang saya kata, tidak pernah saya jumpa situasi sebegini di Negara Negara lain. Biarpun Negara itu jauh lebih maju (Contoh German, Perancis, Jepun, Korea) yang mana sektor komersial mereka lebih berbentuk “international” berbanding Malaysia yang lebih kepada domestik. Kalau inilah situasinya mungkin boleh diberi alasan yang BM tidak penting kerana lebih banyak berurusan dengan pelanggan “international”. Biarpun begitu, kita lihat ini tidak berlaku di Negara Negara maju, bahkan bahasa kebangsaan mereka tetap diutamakan.
Saya lihat, salah satu faktor utama yang membuat mereka ini memandang lekeh pada bahasa kebangsaan adalah kerana orang Melayu itu sendiri dan juga kerajaan yang memandang rendah pada bahasa kebangsaan sendiri.
Sudah sekian lama saya setuju bahawa orang china tak pasih berbahasa melayu.
Tapi malangnya pelajar china mendapat keputusan cemerlang dalam peperiksaan sijil palaran malaysia bagi mata pelajara bahasa malaysia.(BM).
Macam mana mereka boleh lulus cemerlang sedangkan mereka tak pasih berbahasa Melayu?
Pelik ya. mesti ada yang tak kena. Dimana?
Kita kena bongkar semuanya.
Saya setuju umno/bn yang buat silap dalam banyak perkara dalam negara ini.
UMNO/BN adalah kerajaan. pasti salah duduk pada dirinya.dialah yang buat dasar itu dan dasar ini. Dia juga yang buat acuan.mustahil acuan "buahulu" jadi "kuih lapis"
Adalah tak wajar salah pembangkang yang tak pernah jadi pemerintah negara.
Macam juga rumah tangga. Wajar kah kita salah anak, sedangkan ibubapa yang memcorakkan anak anak mereka.
Ibubapalah yang wajar dipersalahkan, macam juga kerajaan. Kerajaan (pemimpin) adalah ayah kepada rakyat jelata. mengapa rakyat yang dipersalahkan?
abdullah ngah,
setuju dgn ko.. mmg musykil mcm mn diorg bleh dpt A utk paper BM walhal ckp melayu tergagap2 dan pelat mengalahkan org monggol..
mgkn ada salah guna kuasa di peringkat tertentu..
sekali lg aku setuju dgn ko abdullah ngah (9.48)..
malangnya aku yakin PAS x akan dpt membetulkan kesalahan UMNO tu sebaliknya mgkn menjadi lebih teruk lagi. bukti dah ada skrg, PAS bukanlah pejuang Islam / melayu yg sebenar.
dan kalau ikut ckp ko tu (kerajaan, bukan rakyat yg boleh dipersalahkan) maka x payah la buat hudud. sebabnya kalau ada jenayah nnti kerajaan yg salah, bukan rakyat.
atau mungkin kau nak ckp bangsatnya atau teruknya kerajaan pimpinan nik aziz skrg memandangkan kes HIV antara yg tertinggi di antara negeri2 di malaysia nie?
Bila sebut sahaja ultra kiasu melompat lah saya. Tak sabar nak hentam pendirian cauvinis dan rasis depa.
Dulu ada orang yang keluar sini atas nama PENYOKONG DAP. Cuba mempopaganda rasis line DAP. Lama begitu saya pun keluar dengan nama PEMBANGKANG DAP. Selepas dihentam bertalu talu bersama kawan kawan disini, dia dah lama senyap. Tapi ultra kiasu masih berleluasa dinegara ini. Mesti terus dihentam dan dibidas secara bertulis disini dll.
Pemimpin DAP Lim Kit Siang nyata rasis, berkata dan bertindak dengan menggugat ketenteraman negara. Sehingga dia diheret ke Kamunting ditahan dibawah Akta Keselamatan Negara atau ISA.
Calon calon DAP berkempen secara rasis diPRU 1969. Menang lebih kerusi, penganut dan penyokong berarak dengan cara kurang ajar sehingga meletus pergaduhan kaum 13 Mei. Penjahat dan gengster penyokong DAP pun ambil bahagian diperistiwa berdarah itu. Ada tercatit didalam sejarah negara.
Depa dok sokong sekolah vernakular dan pertahankan sekolah Cina. Tak usah harap depa mahu buat kajian apa. MCA yang buat kajian dengan bantuan Kementerian Pelajaran beberapa tahun lalu pun mengakui bahawa ada lebih kurang 1/3 murid murid Sekolah Cina berhenti sekolah (drop out) sebelom SPM. Mereka begitu akan berterusan pemikiran iri hati, hasad dengki, tak faham dan tak mahu terima Perkara 152 Perlembagaan Bahasa Melayu sebagai bahasa perantaraan negara ini dan Perkara 153 berkenaan Kedudukan Istimewa Melayu dan Bumiputera Sabah dan Sarawak.
Sudah berkali kali disebutkan. Perlu diulang berkali kali dan bertalu talu. Depa yang tak mahu terima keadaan itu perlu berhijrah. Malangnya depa yang drop out tidak mampu berhijrah, tidak diterima negara lain. Maka berterusan jadi duri dalam daging di sini.
Kita mesti teruskan hujah hujah kita. Yang keras kepala atau "hardcore" tak boleh diharap bertukar pendirian. Ada yang subversif malahan kominis fahaman dan cara cara mereka. Tetapi ada yang tidak hardcore, terumbang ambing atau pak turut. Itu yang kita harap fahamkan dan sedarkan tanggung jawab mereka sebagai rakyat negara ini.
Saya yaakin banyak yang baca blog ini. Dr Ridhuan telah mengatakan bahawa rencana dia diterjemahkan kedalam bahasa Cina dan disiarkan diakhbar Cina. Tentu ada yang minat masuk kesini baca komen komen kita juga.
Ayuh, kawan kawan. Mari kita teruskan hujah hujah kita. Sebanyak mana yang kita boleh dan buat selamam lamanya.
mmg dari dulu saya akui kwn2 bangsa cina tk tahu berbahasa melayu dgn betul. tp result exam cemerlang.. sy pon tk pasti kenapa... mungkin betul kerajaan perlu pandang serius perkara ini. mungkin kita terlalu bertoleransi dgn kaum ini? sbb itu mereka naik junjung dan mengatakan mereka lebih hebat dan mendabik dada!
Saudara RT
membaca posting anda pada kali ini. dalam hati saya bertanya
" kalau begini lah keadaan nya akan terbina kah suatu bentuk perpaduan yang jitu diantara kita rakayat malaysia "
" slogan 1Malaysia nampaknya tak membawa kita kemana pun "
ikhlas saya kata, dari penilaian peribadi saya
" hanya Umno saja yang mahu merealisasikan semangat 1Malaysia, sedangkan rerakan Umno tidak pun berusaha ke arah itu "
ikhlas juga saya kata, ikut yang saya nampak
" hanya Umno saja yang sanggup berkorban dengan mengorbankan hak2 dan kepentingan melayu kepada bukan melayu, sedangkan rerakan Umno sedikit pun tidak berganjak daripada apa yang mereka tuntut "
pada saya keadaan ini adalah
" hanya untung kepada bukan melayu dan ultra kiasu tetapi merugikan kepada melayu dan islam "
sambungan ....
ada pun sebab kenapa keadaan ini berlaku adalah
" orang lain bersatu dalam diam tapi orang melayu perpecah secara terang-terangan "
pertanyaan untuk di renung2kan
" apa kah para pemimpin dalam Umno dan Pas masih lagi tidak mahu sedar. sedangkan kami yang di bawah ini sudah nampak di hadapan ada musibah besar yang sedang menanti kita orang melayu dan islam "
1 Malaysia ! Best of the Best !
Yang terbaik akan digabungkan menjadi BESTA !
84% dah faham 1Malaysia dan ia merupakan konsep yang amat mudah difahami. Mana nak cari yang 16% tu - carilah di blog Ridhuantee dan Deminegara hahahahahaha...
Sdr. Abdullah Ngah,
Ingin saya memaklomkan bahawa sukatan pelajaran dan tahap kelulusan BM disekolah Cina adalah lebih rendah dari Sekolah Kebangsaan. Telah berlaku secara ini dengan diam diam sedemikian lama.
Ini yang peliknya, bukan sebenarnya pelik banyak diantara mereka yang lulus A dalam BM.
Bagusnya Timabalan Perdana Menteri merangkap Menteri Pelajaran Tan Sri Muhyiddin mengambil tindakan diatas ke-tidak seimbangan perkara ini. Bukan sahaja tidak seimbang, juga tidak adil kapada murid murid disekolah kebangsaan.
Telah diputuskan tahun lalu bahawa sukatan pelajaran dan tahap kelulusan BM disekolah Cina akan diselaraskan disekolah kebangsaan mulai tahun hadapan.
Murid murid Cina yang lulus A dalam BM disekolah kebangsaan - itu menunjukkan tiada masalah kebolehan mereka lulus baik dalam BM disekolah kebangsaan. Tiada masalah BM dan pengajaran BM disekolah kebangsaan.
izz,
Sila juga lihat komen saya kapada Sdr. Abdullah Ngah pada 10:37 AM. Terima kasih.
DinTurtle
Yang 16% tu bukan kat sini dan blog DemiNegara sahaja...dekat blog saudara pun ada jugak :)
_________________________________
Anon 10:37am dan Izz,
Keputusan peperiksaan A atau tidak bukan lah pengukur sebenar keupayaan seseorang didalam BM dan juga subjek subjek lain termasuk sains dan matematik.
Banyak (terutama orang Cina yang Ultrakiasu) yang belajar menghafal dan latih tubi bentuk soalan yang sama dengan peperiksaan untuk lulus cemerlang didalam peperiksaan...maka tidak hairanlah jika mendapat A dalam peperiksaan...Tentang kefahaman dan praktikal itu adalah hal yang berlainan.
Saya ada seorang kawan yang berjawatan besar didalam syarikat "MNC" Shell dan sekarang bekerja di Holland. Dia banyak temuduga orang Cina dan orang Melayu yang nak bekerja dengan Shell. Dia kata atas kertas dan temuduga memang orang Cina nampak hebat. Mereka memang pandai "menjual" diri dan keputusan peperiksaan pun mantap tetapi apabila buat kerja yang sebenar..haram tak tahu! Yang Melayu ni banyak "malu malu", time interview memang teruk, atas kertas pun tak seberapa....tapi bila buat kerja tak semestinya teruk...ada yang lebih pandai dan lagi bagus dari orang Cina!
Saya sendiri pun banyak pengalaman berurusan dan bekerja dengan orang orang sebegini. Atas kertas memang nampak bagus. Ada yang mempunyai Phd tapi bila bab kerja...kantoi...aplikasi dan teori entah kemana.
Dan lagi satu; macam mana boleh kata dapat "A" dalam matematik kalau masih bising mempertikai kuota kuota "rasis" yang ditetap kan kerajaan? Mereka kata tak "equal"? Kalau orang itu benar benar faham matematik, pasti tidak akan timbul soalan dan pertikaian sebegini!!!??
Setelah hampir 54 tahun kita merdeka. Bangsa melayu semakin hilang jati diri. Sedar kah kita apa saja yang berkait dengan melayu sedang bergerak sedikit demi sedikit menuju ke arah kepupusan. Bahasa Melayu adalah warisan kepada mereka yang sayang dan cintakan negara ini hanya bahasa ini sajalah yang boleh mengujudkan perpaduan bangsa dan keharmonian negara.
ikhwan,
Amacam kita nak tukarkan tabi'at "malu malu" Melayu nih? Supaya jadi "confident", "forward", "pandai jual diri" dan "assertive".
Saya pun dah lama fikirkan perkara ini. Nampaknya so'al budaya, berbahasa halus, bertabi'at sopan, merendah diri, beradab dan sepertinya yang ada Melayu kata ciri ciri murni yang kita nak simpan.
Amacam? Revolusi Budaya kita? Di China dizaman Mao Zedong, Cultural Revolution dia bawak porak peranda sehingga lk 3o juta rakyat Cina mati akibatnya dan akibat jahanam ekonomi.
Saya sokong penuh buku "The malay Dilemma" Tun Dr Mahathir. Buang pepatah menjahanamkan seperti biar mati anak jangan mati adat dan sebagainya.
Kalau tak macam mana nak tanding dengan ultra kiasu. Mereka guna cara kongsi gelap, penjahat dan gengster, juga cara kominis subversif. Mereka tak hormatkan BM, tak mahu ratakan padang dan sebagainya.
Dr Mahathir kata dia nak "re-visit" bukunya The Malay Dilemma itu. Dia responding well to chest infection diIJN, katanya. Kita do'akan dia panjang umur berpuluh tahun dan keluarkan buku buku yang memberangsangkan bangsa Melayu lagi.
Kalau ada pendapat macam mana nak tukarkan tabi'at Melayu "malu malu" dan "selalu mengalah" itu, saya minat nak dengar.
Tambah:
Cultural Revolution diChina tu sebenarnya helah politik Mao Zedong nak kuatkan kedudukan politiknya yang rebeh dimasa itu.
Di tipunya rakyat Cina, katakan semua orang boleh bersuara mengecam pemerintah, bila dah tahu, dijahanamkan pengkritik dia. Cara kominis yang amat kominis.
Kalau iita diMalaysia buat Revolusi Budaya tapi untuk naikkan semangat, watak dan pendirian Melayu macam mana?
kalau terasa kehilangan identiti rujuk saja ditanah besar China disana berlambak bahan rujukan yg boleh dirujuk. Tp lain halnya dgn di Malaysia, disini dimana kita nak rujuk jika terhakis peradaban melayu, Indon? sama ke melayu Malaysia dgn melayu Indon.Kadang2 terasa Kerajaan yg ada skrg ini mcm satu kerajaan yg bodoh, lembik dan tak langsung memikirkan nasib keseluruhan rakyat Malaysia, semuanya menjadi semakin busuk dan hanyir dlm keserakahan mengejar undi.
langau
Tak faham maksud anda.
Apa kena mengena dengan melayu Indon? Apa makna "memikirkan nasib keseluruhan rakyat Malaysia"?
Salam...
abdullah ngah dan izz
Rasanya perlu buat peratus yang cemerlang BM dengan peratus yang gagal BM...
Surat khabar je yang suka highlight pelajar Cina yang cemerlang... ramai lagi pelajar Melayu yang cemerlang ( tapi itu bukan berita... ( jika anjing gigit manusia itu bukan berita..kalau manusia yang gigit anjing itulah baru berita ). Hasilnya perpepsi org Malaysia.. org cina cemerlang.. melayu ... tak cemerlang.. Harap surat khabar sudah-sudahlah highlight kecemerlangan yang sedikit dengan menafikan kecemerlangan yang banyak...
lebih-lebih lagi pasal STPM... pelajar Melayu yang pandai2 ramai masuk matrikulasi... tinggal yang kurang bernasib baik sahaja... itupun ramai juga yang cemerlang... sila lah cari peratusnya...
( SAYA SETUJU DGN PAPER YG HIGHLIGHT MCM TOKOH MAAL HIJRAH.. ADIK CINA YANG TAK KEKOK PAKAI TUDUNG DAN BAJU KURUNG DAN DAPAT CEMERLANG DALAM MATAPELAJARAN PENDIDIKAN ISLAM ... ( ATAS DASAR DAKWAH & CHALANGE ORG MELAYU ISLAM )
kepada anak bukit hijau,
jawapnya senang, malaysia negara emigrant masa lalu...
Merdeka melalui kesefahaman sesama ... RT ini cuma hendak menunjuk diri pembela bahasa melayu (mungkin dialah ada kiblatnya sendiri).. apa salahnya pada hari ini?
kebebasan berbahasa, cuma bahasa melayu diambil sebagai bahasa kebangasaan ...
I wonder why there's no fault when Malays are sent to Egypt?Does this make them *******?Send them to China and Taiwan also la so that Malays become more KIASU.Sir u should hentam Melayu juga ok?
melayu Indon dan Melayu Malaysia umpama dua suku kaum yg berbeza, tidak spt China Malaysia yg Indentitinya boleh dirujuk sepenuhnya di China.tak kiralah Hakka, Kantonis, Fujian, Hainan atau apa saja semuanya tlh sempurna disana. Melayu Malaysia? harus dirujuk dimana, filipin,mauritius, indon,Afrika..
Kerajaan perlu membuat satu keputusan agar halatuju di dlm kepelbagaian ini tidak menjadi barah.
Anonymous 2.28 p.m,
How can u compare malay studying @ egypt with chinese studying @ Taiwan..?
1st thing 1st, Egyptian is not Malay, but Taiwanese is Chinese.
The culture and the language is different between Malay and Egyptian, but what is the difference between Taiwan Chinese with Malaysian Chinese..?
With ultra-kiasu Malaysian Chinese's policy " China 1st", there is no difference at all..
Yup, why not..send malays and bumis to china or taiwan..nothing wrong with that..Definately will not generate kiasus..heh.
Anon 12:18pm
Macam mana nak tukar tabiat "malu malu" melayu?
Tak tahulah...dah memang macam itu sikap orang melayu termasuklah terlampau berlemah lembut dan beralah....saya tak rasa ada salah pun dengan tabiat tu....
Cuma masalah nya dan yang dikasihankan adalah mereka ni terpaksa berdepan dan bersaing dengan puak ultrakiasu yang kurang ajar dan tak ada "compassion"....kalau beginilah sikap mereka (Org melayu) memang asyik kena buli je la dengan puak puak tak sedar diri ni....
Rasanya terpulang kepada individu masing masing... kita kena pupuk jati diri dan kena terapkan pada anak anak yang masih kecil supaya jangan terlalu rasa rendah diri. Kita ini (Melayu) setanding dengan bangsa bangsa lain. Barulah rasanya ada keyakinan diri sedikit pada anak anak muda bangsa Melayu.
Ini dari kecik, di "basuh" dengan dalam tv, surat khabar; orang putih hebat, orang putih pandai, Cina pandai berniaga, Cina pandai...bla bla..bla...bila dah besar budak tu...goyah lah agaknya semangat dan jati diri...
Terus terang saya katakan saya pun tak tahu...
Wallahua'lam
Totally agree with "lagi biasa dari kebiasaan".
This anon 2:28pm is comparing apple with orange!!?? He/She cant even hide his/her anti Islam feeling. Well I can see it clearly from his comment.
See... we are talking about not sending chinese to the chinese dominant country so as to avoid them from being kiasu,
Out of so many countries out there that Malay have been sent out, including America, Australia, England, Russia, India and others...all that he could think of for rebuttal is why not fault Malay that has been sent to Egypt!!??
Err..why not fault Malay that has been sent to England and other countries!!??
Err.. what is the similarity of sending cina to Taiwan and Malay to Egypt???
How can we have an intelligent debate or discussion when you people could not even made a smart and logical comparison!!??
It is funny when I think of some of the Malay that think this people (ultrakiasu) are smarter than them!!??
Sdr ikhwan
Jangan marah saya nak tanya sikit. Saya tak faham bahasa Arab tapi bukan kah Wallahua'lam tu maknanya Tuhan saja yang mengtahui.
Jika betul, tak ke kita nampak tak confident bila selalu mengakhiri kata kata dengan perkataan itu.
Saya faham bahawa tiada siapa yang mengtahui benar tidak sesuatu yang tidak nyata itu melainkan Allah. Tetapi perlu kah kita selalu buat demikian.
Macam saya kata, harap jangan marah. Saya bertanya, bukan mengata.
Err..why not fault Malay that has been sent to England and other countries!!??
Becoz their technology is superb.It is good for our country.
Err.. what is the similarity of sending cina to Taiwan and Malay to Egypt???
As people know,Egypt is a Muslim country.Malaysia is a Muslim country right?So,Muslim to Muslim.The point is Egpyt is very corrupted country.Evidence?U you know man.I am scared to see this good humble ppl will turn to **** Ada lagi ka good culture in Egypt yang boleh dibawa balik Malaysia??In addition to be controlled by Jews?Hantar bekalan untuk Palestine pun tidak sampai?I know there are many Malays there than other countries for studying Medic and religion.But why Egypt?Apabila berada di negara Islam jati diri tidak berubah tambahan duitnya murah?Fyi,duit Malaysia lagi mahal dari negara China.Tamadun China lebih gah dari Tamadun Mesir.Let's change our taste!
Anon 6:58pm
Tak marah...Adakah anda orang Islam?
Sebagai orang Islam; kalau letak wallahua'lam itu bermakna kita merendah diri pada Allah (Yang ni patut kita merendah diri tapi bukan pada ultrakiasu)!...Ya...ia membawa maksud Allah lebih mengetahui.
Dan tak ada kaitan dengan samada saya yakin atau tidak dengan pendapat saya sendiri....Kalau orang lain nampak saya macam tak yakin kerana ayat tersebut...terpulanglah...
Tapi bagi saya...ayat (wallahua'lam) tersebutlah yang menambahkan lagi keyakinan...
Harap maklum
wallahua'lam.
Anon 7:26pm
Why not give yourself some nickname? Easier to remember and to address you.
Ohh... so are you acknowledging that Malaysia is a Muslim country? No more 3in1 Malaysia, Malaysian Malaysia? Unity in diversity? :) ?!!?
Anyway...you should restate yourself first before you jump on to such comparison in rebuttal to Dr Ridhuan. He is looking from "racism" point of view while you are looking from "religionists" point of view. So really is...as I stated before, your comparison does not make sense given the context of Dr Ridhuan article.
I'll address your other points later.
__________________________________
To Orang PAS and UMNO and everybody;
See...this anon 7:26pm is one of the example of the NONS that I talked/mentioned before...
Deep down in their heart, all they really are, basically is anti Islam and anti Malay....
Yeah they said that "Err..why not fault Malay that has been sent to England and other countries!!?
Becoz their technology is superb.It is good for our country."
That technology superb stuff is just the cover up...What they really means is actually because Egypt is Islamic country....err what is wrong being an Islamic country??? anyway???.
These are the people that made up the vast majority of DAP and MCA....
How could we be an alliance with this sort of people!!??
Anon 7:11 PM,
Hahaha "Tamadun China lebih gah dari Tamadun Mesir."
What criteria you use man? You know meaning of criteria ha?
Want people to write why China 3,500 years recorded history and 5,000 years if including unrecorded history was regarded by Western countries as a pariah until only 10-20 years ago ha? The country, the history not the culture ha?
You don't know ha, China corruption very big even 2,000 years ago ha? You heard about consort families and the eunuchs in the Emperors' palaces ha? They very corrupt one for very long time, you know. You know China very corrupt until now ha? Death penalty for corruption in China oso very much corruption la.
Cannot "change taste" for China la brader.
Ikhwan,
Saya mahu hentam kenapa orang islam mesti menuntut ilmu di negara islam.Saya begini disebabkan orang islam hentam orang Cina menuntut ilmu di negara Cina.Itu main point saya.
Alaaa....nak belajar mana pun sama...asalkan ilmu itu dikongsi....tp orang2 yang belajar dinegara China kebanyakkan tidak mau kasi ilmu diajar pd orang lain....bukti memang jelas ada.....bila ditanya oooo.....rahsia. Ni memang nyata....sebab dah berlaku pd rakan2 aku.....so orang melayu tak kedekut ilmu....sebab kita tau sebarkan ilmu itu adalah kewajipan dan mendapat pahala....lagi satu bila belajar kat Egypt or mana2 negara arab pun org melayu belajar bahasa arab sekali sebabnya Al-Quran itu bahasa arab bukan bahasa Tionghua or bahasa Melayu....bukan macam Bible yg leh ditukar berbagai bahasa....maaf jika ada terasa.....May Allah Bless we all....aminnnn....
>>>>Berapa ramai ahli politik dan ahli perniagaan Cina apabila disoal dalam bahasa Melayu, terus tiba-tiba beralih kepada bahasa Inggeris atau bahasa ibunda. Jelas-jelas menunjukkan bahawa mereka tidak boleh berbahasa kebangsaan. <<<< Sepatutnya wartawan berkata begini "YB' Saya sekolah dalam negara Malaysia jadi bahasa penghantar adalah Bahasa Malaysia maka haruslah YB guna bahasa Malaysia". Tp wartawan takut. Takut kena buang kojer.....alahai.... nk berkata benar tp takut rezki hilang.
Anon 7.7 p.m,
If you read carefully, ikhwan already answered your statement there.
Like what ikhwan wrote b4, u r seeing things from religionist point of view, which is clearly off topic.
If you want to compare so badly, I teach u how.
Comparison for muslim studying at egypt, is buddhist studying at India/China, or christian studying at Vatican City..etc.
Dr. T wrote from Racism point of view, which means Chinese going taiwan, same like malay going to Indonesia..( I think only Indonesia the closest country to Malay culture I can think of, itupun x cukup melayu), or Indian going to India...
See the difference...?
The point is, with these ultra kiasu in Malaysia sudah cukup ultra-kiasu nyer, we don't want sending them there will increase tahap kekiasuan mereka...
U know that stupid namewee? x pandai ckp bahasa malaysia, sampai taiwan, look what he did?
And I don't know why the gov still keep him. His citizenship should be revoke. So, die boleh blah dok taiwan.
My 2 cents.
anon 7.57 p.m,
y org cina tanak belajar di india?Medic kat india pun ok per..?
lagi_biasa_dr_kebiasaan,
Support what you said at 12:13 AM. It's worth more than 2 cents.
akhbar halatujunya untung dan rugi disamping propaganda untuk pemiliknya.
Oleh itu soal ia berita atau tidak hanya manipulasi saja.
sebab itu soal halal haram tidak menjadi had yang perlu dijaga asalkan mendatangkan keuntungan politik.
Dalam hal ini dimanakah kiblatnya tidak timbul sama sekali.
Yang penting bagi mereka ialah propaganda menjadi dasar supaya pemerintah itu dinilai sah baik oleh rakyat.
Saya pernah pergi BTN Kursus Kenegaraan. Dalam aktiviti kumpulan, saya diletakkan satu satu kumpulan tegar di mana termasuk juga dua orang pelajar Cina perempuan yang akan melanjutkan pelajarannya ke negara China.
Tentang dua orang Cina tu, ditaja JPA untuk buat PhD dalam bidang kebudayaan China. Persoalannya, apa yang komersilnya pengajian dalam kebudayaan China sampai ditaja oleh JPA? Keutamaan patutnya dalam bidang yang mempunyai nilai komersil seperti juga yang selalu dipersoalkan tentang pilihan bidang pengajian pelajar Melayu yang ditaja.
Saya nak jawapan soalan dimana kiblat kita ini dengan jawapan bahawa kerajaan yang memerintah dulu dan sekarang ini tidak punya kiblat, sebab itu jadi haru biru dalam semua perkara, termasuk dalam bidang politik, pendidikan, kebudayaan dan sosial sehingga malaysia menduduki tempat ke 10 minun arak.
Jika kerajaan ada kiblat mana mungkin berlaku berlaku demikian, sedangkan negara kafir, termasuk China mengadakan had pengawalan terhadap peminun arak negaranya.
Kiblat kerajaan kita hanya pungutan hasil tanpa melihat implikasinya terhadap rakyat yang di pimpinnya.
wayau,
Setuju dengan pendapat anda. So'alan anda tepat sekali.
Inilah yang kadang kadang nampak kelam kabut JPA dibuat pemimpin politik. Begitu juga BTN.
Muhyiddin pulak suruh JPA kaji komplen Tmbalannya Wee wee pasal kononnya ada beberapa murid Cina dapat 8-9A tak diberi biasiswa. Nampak macam nak melutut juga seperti bossnya, Najib. Pada hal Cina kaum yang terkaya dinegara ini dan ada sistem bantu membantu diantara mereka, demikian banyak jutawan Cina yang mahu menyumbang bisiswa dsbnya sehingga UTAR tidak mahu terima RM30 juta dari seorang jurutera jutawan Cina ditahun lalu.
Yang digelar Wee wee itu pulak menerjah macam gengster, komplen diakhbar sana sini, tidak melalui saluran BN yang MCA jadi ahli. Apa ni?
Tapi sikit menyenangkan bahawa Muhyiddin kata ada Ketua Pengarah JPA buat taklimat kapadanya sebelom itu berkenaan dasar dasar (basis) atau kriteria yang digunakan bagi pemberian biasiswa. Bukan straight As saja. Ada faktor faktor lain yang diambil kira. Dia arahkan KP JPA ikut kriteria tersebut.
Saya reda hati sikit bila mikirkan bahawa ada pegawai pegawai Kerajaan yang menggunakan kebijaksanaan (discretion) mereka dalam melaksanakan dasar (policy) Kerajaan. Mereka perlu berbuat demikian. Mereka mesti teruskan berbuat demikian. Untuk kesejahteraan dan keamanan negara jangka masa panjang.
Orang politik buat dasar merintah selalunya banyak berdasarkan undi. Pegawai Kerajaan mengimplementasi perlu dari segi praktiknya, juga mengambil kira keperluan undi bagi sesiapa pemimpin politik yang menjadi boss mereka, tetapi tidak amat sesangat terikat kapada perkara undi. Ada berbagai undang undang, peraturan, garis panduan dan "precedent" yang mereka perlu ambil kira juga.
Saya bangga dengan mereka diBTN dan JPA yang sentiasa terus mempertahankan langkah langkah bagi mendapatkan perpaduan negara dijangka masa panjang. Syabas kapada mereka. Mereka mempunyai, dan diberi kebijaksanaan (discretion) dibawah mana mana undang undang atau peraturan pun. Dan mereka boleh gunakan kebijaksanaan itu bila bila perlu.
Pemerintahan dimana mana negara mesti ada sistem pemimpin politik dan pelaksana polisi - bureaukrat atau pegawai pegawai perkhidmatan awam. Tidak boleh lari dari itu. Itu yang dinamakan demokrasi.
Abdullah Ngah,
Siapa cakap "malaysia menduduki tempat ke 10 minun arak"?
Beri punca maklumat dan sedikit penerngan lah. Supaya orang boleh percaya.
wayau,
Saya pun tak nampak apa aspek komersial nya bagi PhD dalam bidang kebudayaan Cina. Pelik JPA hantar mereka buat kursus demikian.
Jika bidang Kejuruteraan ke, atau Matematik ke lain lah jugak. Tak faham apa maksud dan tujuan JPA itu.
Kalau aspek aspek khas kebudayaan China seperti seni lukis atau seni porcelain art yang China mashur baginya, lain jugak.
Saya harap tidak kebudayaan pada umumnya yang boleh dipolitikkan. Seperti ada dikata disini pasal Revolusi Budaya atau "Cultural Revolution". Itu politik, bukan budaya. Pada interpretasi luasnya, itu budaya jugak tapi budaya komunis, dan negara ini mengharamkam konsep komunisme.
Apa pun, asalkan jangan kursus kursus yang mereka akan berkiblat keChina.
-ikhwan-
Anon 2:22pm
Anda tulis:
________________________________
kepada anak bukit hijau,
jawapnya senang, malaysia negara emigrant masa lalu...
________________________________
Komen saya: Apa maksud anda dengan negara emigrant? Pada masa dahulu negara ini dikenali sebagai Tanah Melayu. Ini bukan negara emigrant. Buat pengetahuan anda proses "migration" ini masih lagi berlaku sehingga sekarang bukan sahaja di zaman dahulu, bukan sahaja di Malaysia tetapi diseluruh dunia.
Lagi dari anda:
_________________________________
Merdeka melalui kesefahaman sesama ... RT ini cuma hendak menunjuk diri pembela bahasa melayu (mungkin dialah ada kiblatnya sendiri).. apa salahnya pada hari ini?
_________________________________
Tak faham??? Boleh terangkan lagi?
Dan lagi:
________________________________
kebebasan berbahasa, cuma bahasa melayu diambil sebagai bahasa kebangasaan ...
__________________________________
Komen saya: Ya, memang bebas berbahasa tetapi bahasa Kebangsaan adalah bahasa Melayu. Bahasa Kebangsaan bukanlah hanya pada nama tetapi mesti juga dipraktikkan. Apa guna nama bahasa kebangsaan? jika ianya dilayan sama seperti bahasa bahasa lain. Kalau begitu, baik tak payah letak nama "bahasa kebangsaan"!!.
Ianya Mestilah dikuasai dan mestilah digunakan untuk papan papan tanda umum contohnya di kedai kedai, iklan, surat khabar dan menyampai berita di TV.
-ikhwan-
Continue from yesterday to address comment from Anon 7:11pm
Anon 7:11pm said:
___________________________________
The point is Egpyt is very corrupted country.Evidence?U you know man.I am scared to see this good humble ppl will turn to **** Ada lagi ka good culture in Egypt yang boleh dibawa balik Malaysia??
___________________________________
My friend...
You are making the wrong remark there....Those Malay that went to Egypt does not bring back their culture. They only bring back their Islamic or medical knowledge. Yes the country was corrupt (Not sure with the change of government today)but the learning institution are not in anyway affected by this.
And by the way, most of those UMNO and PKR, corrupt Malay does not graduate from Egypt. They graduate from England, America etc from that Oxford, Cambridge, Harvard etc like that person with initial "KJ" (you know lah who I am referring to).
So my point is...they dont bring back culture...they bring back knowledge! and whether you are corrupt or not does not depend on where you learn from. It depends solely on the individual morality.
What about Taiwan and China? Are you sure that these countries arent corrupted??!! And Cina Malaysia learning in Taiwan and China definitely is not good. They didnt just bring back knowledge...they also bring back more ultrakiasu! We definitely dont want this.
I definitely support sending Malay to these chinese country but not Cina Malaysia to chinese country.
And more:
_________________________________
In addition to be controlled by Jews?Hantar bekalan untuk Palestine pun tidak sampai?I know there are many Malays there than other countries for studying Medic and religion.But why Egypt?
________________________________
My comment: Totally agree with you on that Jew part under the old government. Hopefully not under this new government that they formed due to the revolution.
And further he said:
________________________________
Apabila berada di negara Islam jati diri tidak berubah tambahan duitnya murah?
__________________________________
My response: Tambahan duitnya murah? Sebab duit murah lah kita nak hantar. Tak ada lah kerajaan kena habiskan duit banyak untuk mendapatkan ilmu Islam yang berkualiti.
Kenapa pula kita (Org Melayu) kena ubah jati diri? Jati diri orang Melayu sudah bertepatan dengan bangsa Malaysia mengikut perlembagaan.
Masalahnya Orang Cina di Malaysia ini tidak mempunyai jati diri sebagai bangsa Malaysia. kemudian dihantar pula ke negara negara Cina. Maka sampai kesudah lah orang orang anda tidak akan menukarkan jati diri mereka kepada jati diri yang sepatutnya sebagai rakyat Malaysia. Bertambah kiasu lah jawabnya.
And more from Anon 7:11pm:
__________________________________
Fyi,duit Malaysia lagi mahal dari negara China.Tamadun China lebih gah dari Tamadun Mesir.Let's change our taste!
__________________________________
Sorry saya Tak faham apa logiknya??! So nak change taste kemana ni? dari Mesir ke Cina dan kemudian ke Malaysia?
And are you sure that Tamadun China is much better than the Egypt civilization? I dont think so.
With its pyramids and longer, rich history that even predate the China itself; I reckon Tamadun Egypt is better in comparison to China.
Regards
jangan lupa yang tamadun alam melayu sendiri telah dibuktikan secara ilmiah berusia 5000 tahun. pernah juga mempunyai hubungan dengan tamadun-tamadun besar seperti mesir, greek dan rom. janganlah kita anggap apa-apa pasal melayu ni lekeh berbanding dengan cina.
Anon 12:17 PM,
Setuju sepenuhnya.
Nak tambah sikit:
Orang Cina pun kagum dengan tamadun Melayu sejak abad ke7. I Xing, penganut Buddhism, ingin melawat tempat lahir Buddha diIndia (Buddhism datang keChina dari India dan seluruh China telah menganutnya bila samapi abad ke6), naik kapal, singgah diPalembang (Srivijaya) diabad 7 selama 6 bulan, untuk berlajar Sanskrit (Srivijaya Kerajaan Hindu dimasa itu) dan menunggu musim angin yang sesuai.
Dia menulis rekod pelayarannya dan ada diarkeb negeri China hingga sekarang. Dia kata dia naik kapal yang dibuat oleh orang Melayu, besar bertingkat, dari Palembang ke Kedah (kepala negeri Srivijjaya juga pada masa itu - alternative capital) dan kagum dengan kemahiran membuat kapal serta jurumudi.
Dalam tempoh yang lebih kurang sama, seorang Duta negeri China melawat tempat yang direkodnya sebagai "Tanah Merah", dipercayai diLangkasuka, kagum dengan budaya Melayu disana.
Mari kita hebahkan disana sini buku "Tamadun Alam Melayu" dan "The Malay Civilization" yang diterbitkan Persatuan Sejarah Malaysia tahun 2009 itu. Supaya pendatang kenegara ini, yang kebanyaknya bermula diabad 19, hormatkan tamadun Melayu ini.
Penerangan:
"Srivijaya Kerajaan Hindu dimasa itu" tidak bermakna orang India Hindu. Tetapi orang Melayu, budaya Melayu, hanya beragama Hindu.
Islam masuk kerantau ini hanya diabad 13.
Tambahan kepada Anon 12:17 PM, untuk difikir-fikirkan bersama (?).
Apabila disebut Melayu, maksudnya adalah manusia yang berasal dari rantau Asia Tenggara/Nusantara dan TIDAK TERHAD kepada Melayu di Malaysia sahaja.
Banyak lagi sebenarnya tapi sedikit di antaranya:
1. Melayu berasal dari keturunan nabi Ibrahim. Jadi tidak hairan jika agama Hanif wujud di nusantara dan dianuti oleh Melayu. Jangan tuduh Melayu tidak ada agama/pagan/animisme.
2. Islam pernah sampai ke nusantara sewaktu Rasulullah masih hidup lagi. Buktinya, jika Srivijaya/Zabag dikenali oleh orang Arab sebelum lahirnya Rasullullah dan pada waktu baginda diutus menjadi rasul telah menjadi kerajaan besar, adalah tidak mustahil Rasulullah telah mengutus surat menyeru kepada Islam sama seperti seruan kepada kerajaan-kerajaan besar lain.
3. Bangsa Melayu pernah terlibat berjihad membantu tentera Islam semasa perang Salib.
4. Macam ditulis oleh anon sebelum ini, bangsa China tidak tahu membuat jong sebab mereka bukan bangsa pelaut. Bangsa China mahir membuat jong setelah mempelajari cara membuatnya dari bangsa Melayu.
Maaf masuk sejarah sikit. Tapi adalah penting untuk kita cerahkan kembali sejarah kita yang selama ini digelapkan dikala kita diasak disegenap penjuru oleh musuh Islam termasuk ultrakiasu sendiri.
Perlu ditegaskan yang rantau nusantara adalah luas dan bangsa Melayu memang berasal dari sini dan di sinilah sepatutnya kiblat kita termasuk kepada pendatang yang datang ke sini (kiblat kaabah tu cerita lain).
Jangan nak kata yang Melayu tu berasal dari Yunnan. Silap-silap kaum asal Yunnan tu sendiri ada kaitan dengan Melayu sebab sempadan utara wilayah Melayu dahulukala adalah sehingga ke utara Vietnam termasuk Laos dan Kemboja malah sampai ke Tenaserim di Burma.
Saya sokong penuh pendapat Anonymous 3:25 PM supaya semua diMalaysia berkiblatkan rantau ini, khasnya Malaysia ini sendiri. Tidak lain dan tidak bukan.
Orang Melayu Campa masih ada diVietnam dan Cambodia. Suatu seminar telah didakan berkenaan Manuskrip Melayu Campa, Warian Tamadun Melayu, di Kuala Lumpur, 6-7 Disember 2004, melibatkan usaha usaha UNESCO, Jabatan Muzium dan Antikuiti dan pakar pakar tempatan. Kuala Lumpur telah disyorkan menjadi pusat pengumpulan dan pengkajian manuskrip Melayu Campa.
Sila lihat buku bertajuk "Prosiding Seminar Manuskrip Melayu Campa, Warisan Tamadun Melayu, penerbitan Jabatan Muzium dan Antikuiti, yang boleh dibeli dari Muzium Negara. Disitu juga boleh dibeli buku "Tamadun Alam Melayu" penerbitan 2009 dan "The Malay Civilization" penerbitan 2007, kedua duanya oleh Persatuan Sejarah Malaysia.
Akhbar milik MCA, The Star semalam menyiarkan statistik tahun ini yang dikeluarkan oleh Pertubuhan Kesihatan Dunia (WHO) bahawa Malaysia menduduki "ranking Top 10" peminum arak paling ramai di dunia.
WHO turut menjelaskan, Malaysia membelanjakan US$500 juta (RM1.5 bilion) untuk alkohol dengan kadar penggunaan per kapita sebanyak 7 liter, manakala penggunaan beer di Malaysia pula mencecah 11 liter per kapita.
inilah punca kebabrokan berleluasa dan bermaharajalela serta menjadi sukar menyelesaikanya.
Bayangkan arak itu ibu segala kemungkaran (kejahatan).
Jelas negara kita berkiblat kepada kafisme.
Amerika syarikat pernah mengharamkan arak suatu masa dulu, kerana memberi kesan buruk dan berbahaya kepada rakyatnya.
Salam...
Saya hanya ingin memberi pandangan saya....
jika kita asyik salah menyalah dan tuduh menuduh, masalah perkauman ini tidak akan selesai....
aper kater rakan2 sumer memberikan idea sebagai jln penyelesaian kpd permasalahan...bukan nya mencari setiap inci masalah setiap kaum....
saya bukan penyokong or pengutuk ultra kiasu atau pengkhianat bangsa....disini saya ini memberikan pengalaman saya sebagai seorang guru yg pernah bekerja di sekolah swasta kepunyaan ultrakiasu dan murid2nya pula anak2 ultrakiasu....
sebenarnya masalah ini berlaku kerana kita tidak cuba utk mengenali hati budi sesama kita termasuk melayu, cina dan india....
di dalam hati kita telah terselit dr kecil cerita yg dimomokkan oleh ibu bapa kiter ttg perkauman ini termasuklah juga keluarga ultrakiasu.....
jika kita cuba mengenali dan berkongsi adat budaya kiter kpd mereka nescaya mereka dgn tangan terbuka akan cuba mengnali adat resam org melayu begitu juga kita akan mengenali adat budaya mrk....
pelajar2 saya dahulu terdiri drpd pelajar sek ren....hati mereka sgt suci dan bersih.....apa yg penting adalah kita sbg org dewasa mesti memberitahu mrk nilai2 murni dan semangat patriotik kpd mrk....ini lah peranan sek dan juga guru....
mmg la ader sesetengah ibu bapa yg agak ortodok ttg kaum melayu....tapi saya sbg guru dan juga org dewasa akan menunjukkan sikap yg terpuji dan yg ader nilai2 murni spy tanggapan negatif mrk akan lenyap dan mrk akan igt sampai bila2.....
janganlah kita menunjukan sikap2 neagtif melayu spt malas berusaha...itu adalah sinonim dgn sikap sesetengah melayu kita....jika kita menunjukkan sikap rajin dan ikhlas...tuhan akan membalasnya....sy tidak dinafikan ttg sikap ultrakiasu yg sgt bias...tp mrk ini adalah generasi yg lahir sebelum merdeka dan bbrpa tahun slps merdeka jd sikap perkauman sgt2 jelas....saya rasa disekeliling saya yg bergenerasi baru ini sgt jelas kami bersikap terbuka antara satu sama lain....( sy mempunyai ramai rakan berbangsa cina dan india walaupon sy bersekolah di sek keb dan MRSM serta universiti yg dipenuhi org melayu....walaopon pada mulanya sy berasa kekok berkawan dgn mrk kerana tidak biasa.....tapi apa yg penting kita mesti berusaha utk bercampor dgn bangsa lain dan berfikiran positif.(sy rs mereka juga berperasaan begitu)
sy rasa cukoplah saya memberi sedikit pandangan saya yg agak panjang lebar....kalau rase ingin respons komen ini secara positif dan negatif saya alu2alukan...
akhir sekali yg paling penting adalah kerajaan...keraajan haruslah tegas....saya tahu org melayu terkenal dgn budi pekerti yg mulia....tapi jika seseorg ketua keluarga/ negara itu tidak tegas...tentulah org2 dibawahnya akan mengambil kesempatan....
peace!
sy rasa barisan nasional kena ubah cara pentadbiran yg lebih kpd masyarakat majmuk, bukan spt dahulu di mana
umno utk melayu sahaja
mca utk cina shj
mic utk india shj....
* jadikan satu parti itu utk semua...
slm..kiblat kita mana?inilah punca akhirat xdapat dunia pun xdapat.dan ini ketentuan allah jua,terpulang kpdnya jualah sapa yg nak d bimbinginya.yg dh dapat solat dan merasa manisnya iman doa kan org lain pun akn dapat solat n iman juga,bukan berdebat yg tak ada sudahnya..kalau hidup dah bertuhan(allah taala)..apela yg makhluk dpt buat.kalau hidup xda tuhan..hari2 kita risaukan makhluk.yg dah terang lagi nyata bahawa selain dari allah taala,tiada daya upaya lain yg dpt bg mudarat atau munafaat..bukan ultra kiasu yg jadi masalah,diri sendiri yg bermasalah.mana kiblat kita?..walahuaklam.
hmm...it is said tat d kiasu sucks at malay yet they score during spm...it is also said tat kiasu sch exam papers r marked more leniently...o and from random reading the comments i saw someone asking why cant everyone be united under bahasa kebangsaan...one word to sum up what im thinking is-----LOL!
just now i saw a post,forget who saying malay yang cemerlang telah dihantar masuk ke matrikulasi....
omg,please!!if u all have a time,have a look into local matriculation,there r even malay without A in spm get into matriculation...
fine....getting a bad result doesn't mean the end of the world,the important is to work hard once u know u r weak...
but when they r so lucky for getting the enrollment into matriculation compare with other races who really deserved...
some of them totally do not work hard,wasting government money,each semester government pay rm1250 from every student,everyday relax,smoking,disturbing n couple.
n finally getting a "superb result",my ex-roommates getting 3F n 1E....
I realize that matriculation is there to help Malay,but please choose those malay who really deserved n willing to study....
dont make us keep laughing on u all
I'm from an SMJK school and let me put it to you this way. Get your facts right before you talk out of your ass, 'Dr' Tee.
First of all, our command of the Malay language isn't as appalling as you claimed it is, in fact I'm sure we're well above the national school average.
As to your allegations that the majority of SMJK students FAILED BM during SPM, are you high on crack or what? I got a freaking A+ in 2009 and most students in my year got an A or B, if that is any significance to you (Nevermind, I know it isn't).
Fact is, we are somewhat weaker in verbal communication using BM due to a lack of consistent usage on a daily basis. However, we're certainly on par if not, far better in other aspects of the language including grammar and vocabulary, as exemplified by our SPM grades.
And well, 'weak' as we may be, at least we don't butcher the national language with all those nonsensical abbreviations and sentence structures that will make a BM teacher weep. Example: "krng tgk muke ridhuan tee tu, fuck sial mcm beruk je".
Here's another one for you to digest, all languages are given equal emphasis in SMJK schools. We have 6 periods for both BM and Bahasa Cina, 5 for English.
You claimed that students going to Taiwan and China for studies are racist? Mencinakan lagi cina. I don't exactly know how respond to such a stupid question. So I suppose MARA/JPA scholarships sending Malay students to Indonesia for Medicine and other courses is racism as well?
Seriously, YOU have a PhD? Your university must be very ashamed.
before i leave your stupid blog,i saw something very interesting....
"should chinese press to be translated into malay language?"
haha...everyone know nothing since we r born,if we do not know about something,then we have to learn...
now u want to know about what chinese press talking about,maybe they talking something bad on RT,or maybe they talking nonsense....
but you all cant understand,y dont just go and learn,then u will know everything,no need scare about other scold at u or laughing at u...
or maybe u can learn from our brilliant government....
use GOOGLE TRANSLATE!!!!
haha...brilliant enough with a big big shame on every Malaysian face,even Indonesia government can get it right but our government cnt....haha~~
iEda saFuan,
Saya tak tau mcm mana respon positif yang anda maksudkan tpi saya ingin komen.
Betul, jika kita asyik salah menyalah dan tuduh menuduh, masalah perkauman ini tidak akan selesai. Tpi klau kita senyap, tak selesai juga. Malah mangkin teruk.
Bagus anda memberikan idea tpi, untuk berbuat demikian, selalunya kita kena tahu (dan sebutkan) "setiap inci masalah setiap kaum" supaya dapat mengeluarkan idea, tak gitu?
Bagus anda memberikan pengalaman anda sebagai seorang guru disekolah "kepunyaan ultrakiasu dan murid2nya pula anak2 ultrakiasu". Betul, masalah ini berlaku kerana kita tidak cuba utk mengenali hati budi sesama kita termasuk melayu, cina dan india. So'alnya, siapa yang patut ambil "inisiatif" buat demikian?
Harus diingati bahawa Melayu sudah persilakan mereka masuk negara ini - Menteri Larut Ngah Ibrahim telah buat demikian dipertengahan abad 19 lagi, bawa Cina dari Penang (British perintah sebelom negeri negeri Melayu dijajah) untuk memajukan lombong lombongnya, beri modal dan kawasan lombong kapada beberapa diantara mereka untuk buka lombong baru, Ghee Hin dan Hai San balas dengan bawa masuk kongsi gelap, penjahat dan gengster, berbunuh hingga Perang Larut berkali kali, mengheret pelombong pelombong Melayu, sehingga 250 lombong Melayu akhirnya lenyap.
Penjajah British tolong mereka berniaga beri tanah lombong, lesen lombong, lesen judi (senang untung) dan berbagi lagi, buat sekolah rendah, menengah dan Inggeris dibandar dimana banyak Cina tinggal, tetapi hanya 4 tahun sekolah Melayu dikampong, takda sekolah menengah, mintak sekolah Inggeris tidak diberi. Mereka jadi kaum terkaya dan memenuhi lapangan professional dinegara ini, banyak yang tidak hormatkan Perkara 152 Perlembagaan negara fasal BM, Perkara 153 fasal Kedudukan Istimewa Melayu, maka anda jangka Melayu perlu terus angkat kain pergi jumpa diorang tersengeh sengeh lambai dan persilakan itu ini lagi? Saya tak setuju, Puan. Tak patut. Ada hadnya. Giliran mereka melambai lambai kpd kita. Betul tak?
Betul "hati kita telah terselit dr kecil cerita yg dimomokkan oleh ibu bapa kiter ttg perkauman ini". Tapi tak setuju dengan perkataan "termasuklah juga keluarga ultrakiasu". Saya fikir, "terutamanya" mereka ultrakiasu.
Mungkin anda terpengaruh dengan pandangan suci murni dimuka kanak kanak kecil murid anda, dan beberapa emak bapak yang anda kenal nampak tidak ultra kiasu. Tapi cubalah fikir lagi berapa banyak blog dan berapa banyak komen yang menyatakan berlainan dari apa yang anda katakan. Sebagai contoh, bacalah blog seperti Demi Negara, Jebat Must Die, Kempen SSS dll - blog blog yang tidak mencarut tapi ada kata kata yang kadang kadang emosi.
Tidak setuju juga "kita cuba mengenali dan berkongsi adat budaya kiter kpd mereka". Kita mesti berdasarkan sejarah, ini Tanah Melayu, nama dahulu ialah Persekutuan Tanah Melayu, kita berasal diGugusan Pulau Pulau Melayu yang termasuk Semenanjong Tanah Melayu. Mereka pendatang, datang beramai diabad 19. Ini fakta sejarah. Kita tuan rumah. Sudah melambai masuk rumah kita. Respon Perang Larut dll tidak menyenangkan hati kita. Mana boleh kita berterusan tersengeh sengeh, terhegeh hegeh, melayan mereka.
Bukankah mereka sudah dipersetujui dapat hak kerakyatan, dah jadi rakyat Malaysia? Bukankah tanggung jawab mereka patuh kpada dan ikuti Perlembagaan negara sepenuhnya? Maka bukan kah mereka patut "dgn tangan terbuka akan cuba mengnali adat resam org melayu"? Bukankah budaya Malaysia perlu berteraskan budaya Melayu?
[Bersambung]
[Sambungan 1]
Bagus anda memberitahu murid murid anda nilai2 murni dan semangat patriotik kpd mrk. Benar ini lah peranan sek dan juga guru. Saya harapkan semua guru buat demikian dengan gigih dan penuh minat, demi kepentingan kesejahteraan genarasi depan.
Bagus anda juga dapati "mmg la ader sesetengah ibu bapa yg agak ortodok ttg kaum melayu". Bagus azam anda "sbg guru dan juga org dewasa akan menunjukkan sikap yg terpuji dan yg ader nilai2 murni spy tanggapan negatif mrk akan lenyap dan mrk akan igt sampai bila2.."
Benar kita ada "sikap2 neagtif melayu spt malas berusaha" tapi saya harap anda tidak terpengaruh oleh mereka ultrakiasu yang selalu membuat tomahan itu. Lihat sejarah negeri China dan keadaan bukan Melayu dinegara ini pun, mereka juga ada yang malas, diakui mereka sendiri sekali sekala.
Bila anda kata "tidak dinafikan ttg sikap ultrakiasu yg sgt bias", saya tak tau sama ada perkata akhir itu typo dan bermaksud "buas". Memang watak dan tabi'at kongsi gelap, penjahat dan gengster itu masih ada lagi sekarang dinegara ini dan diChinatown merata dunia, walau pun sudah sampai generasi yg lahir sellepas Merdeka, dan sikap perkauman masih sgt2 jelas - lihat saja sepandok DAP, apa yang dikatakan "Malaysian Malaysia" - itu cuba mengikis Kedudukan Istimewa Melayu sebab konsep itu tidak mengakui Kedudukan Istimewa tersebut. Jugak MCA baru baru ini mahukan sasaran ekuiti Bumiputera dihapuskan, sehingga menarik panggilan hak kerakyatan mereka jugak dihapuskan.
Bagus generasi baru ini bersikap terbuka tetapi adalah menjadi naiive atau mentah atau terlalu lurus, atau kurang fahamkan sejarah negara ini jika tidak sedarkan dan ambil kira faktor faktor yang saya sebutkan diatas.
Dasar penubuhan suatu Bangsa Malaysia yang kukuh dan bersepadu itu perlu betul. Jika tidak batu asasnya tidak kuat. Akan terumbang ambing bangunan yang ada jika foundation atau dasarnya tidak betul, tidak kuat. Kita sudah lihat pegaduhan kaum 1969 dan perlu elakkannya, terutama bila mereka ultrakiasu terus memikul sepandok Malaysisn Malaysia kononnya, mengikis hak Melayu, mahukan sasaran ekuiti Bumiputera dihapuskan dan sebagainya.
[lihat Sambungan 2]
[Sambungan 2]
Pelajaran dan kelulusan universiti adalah penting bagi Melayu yang jauh ketinggalan dibelakang akibat polisi penjajahan British yang mahukan Melayu "menjaga pengeluaran makanan", maka dibiarkan mereka Melayu terus jadi petani dan penangkap ikan, hanya Cina maju dilapangan ekonomi dan pelajaran.
Tetapi saya berharap Melayu berkelulusan universiti sedar betapa sedihnya nasib Melayu selama ini sehingga sekarang. Yang malas kita tak mahu tapi yang berpelajaran kita mahukan sedarkan keadaan dan cuba tukarkan keadaan berdasarkan Perlembagaan negara, terutamanya Perkara 152 Bahasa Malaysia dan Perkara 153 Kedudukan Istimewa Melayu. Selagi ada rakat yang tidak hormatkan dan patuhinya, tidak akan timbul harmoni, kemananan dan kesejahteraan jangka masa panjang.
Saya juga mahukan peace, tapi untuk selama lamanya, bukan untuk sesatu tempoh bagi tujuan undi dsbnya sahaja. Konsep "masyarakat majmuk" itu mesti betul asas atau foundation nya.
Setuju "kita mesti berusaha utk bercampor dgn bangsa lain dan berfikiran positif." Anda kata "(sy rs mereka juga berperasaan begitu)" tapi saya fikir perkataannya bukan "juga" tapi "perlu mengambil langkah utama, atau inisiatif, atau menjadi "encumbent upon them" berbuat demikian.
Bagus anda berfikiran luas dan liberal secara mahu menerima "respons komen ini secara positif dan negatif saya alu2alukan..." Saya bangga dengan pendirian seperti ini.
Setuju juga dengan keseluruh kata kata anda yang saya ulangi ini: "yg paling penting adalah kerajaan...keraajan haruslah tegas....saya tahu org melayu terkenal dgn budi pekerti yg mulia....tapi jika seseorg ketua keluarga/ negara itu tidak tegas...tentulah org2 dibawahnya akan mengambil kesempatan...."
Tidak salah sistem yang ada sekarang, berikutan hal bahawa sejak zaman British lagi parti politik dibenarkan timbul berdasarkan bangsa, dan "coaliton" seperti BN cuba mengatasi masalah. Tetapi pemimpim mesti tegas, menentukan ahli BN seperti MCA tidak cuba "melawan tokeh", seperti nyata dari MCA memajukan resolusi mahukan sasaran ekuiti Bumiputera dihapukan.
Dan kata kata serta tindak tanduk Timbalan Menteri Pelajaran yang bising komplen diakhbar, tidak melalui saluran tertentu BN, termasuk mengata dia telah membantah 2-3 kali perkara penyelarasan tahap lulus BM disekolah vernakular dengan sekolah kebangsaan, dan berbuat demikian selepas Kementeriannya sendiri membuat keputusan yang nyata berupa "collective decision" dan membayangkan "will of the majority".
Mister Stupid SMJK blogger leaving this not stupid blog at 1.00AM,
Whether your read this blog again and my comment herein I could't care less. At least anyone else of your kind reading it will know what I think of not only stupid but arrogant, misled and ungrateful blokes like you.
You have a good enough command of English to know the definition of the word "bloke" in the dictionary, but I don't mind if you or any one else interpret it more than that.
Such a pity, your SMJK education is wasted into non-Malaysian thinking line, won't even bother to write in BM, and I gonna reply you in kind, so that the message I bring gets fully drummed into your head.
Who the hell are you to say RT has not got his facts right? You simply won't accept the various arguments based on the many facts he put out, would you? Kiasu thinking fellow who thinks only you got your facts right and even PhD Senior lecturers you simply try to pooh pooh. Well, ppoh pooh to you, old boy. Even some dog pooh to you, too.
Don't talk about your BM being "above the national school average" when you don't put out the data and quote the sources and the authority for saying the shit you said.
Most importantly, you people have for years quietly been having a different BM syllabus and a lower standard of BM pass. The Minister of Education had only last year decided that it would be standardized beginning next year.
Your argument is only to ask, "are you high on crack or what?" Didn't I say you are stupid and arrogant? Also kurang ajar, too. Coming to a blog owned by a PhD Senior Lecturer and saying that sort of gangsterish language. And no proof of your "freaking A+" - you have used the right word - freak! Yet you offer no data on the performance of others.
You disregard the Deputy Minister Wee wee saying last year that a research done the previous years showed that about 1/3 of SRJKC pupils drop out of school before SPM in SKs because of BM? And RT refers to them as well, Mister stupid.
Not having any other arguments you then hit out at abbreviations bloggers use, including the teacher who wrote above you. You never heard about "blogging language", Mister stupido?
We are not interested in "all languages are given equal emphasis in SMJK schools". In fact we abhor that because of non-respect for Bahasa Kebangsaan which is clearly stated in the Constitution as THE language of communication in this country. If you don't understand the significance of the word "THE" as stated in the Constitution, it means your English is not good enough despite knowing grammar and syntax.
Read the Constitution fully, boy. Understand it and interpret it as a Malaysian whose ancestors were stateless and without any citizenship for over a hundred years in this country. Don't just grab the citizenship right that's accorded your kind in the Constitution. Read, understand respect Article 152 on BM and 153 on the Special Position of the Malays and the Bumiputeras of Sarawak and Sabah.
There is no issue at all about MARA/JPA scholarships sending Malay students to Indonesia for Medicine and other courses. Read the books recommended in the earlier comments - "The Malay Civilization" and "Tamadun Alam Melayu" (available at Muzuim Negara or Historical Sociiety Building opposite IJN, Jalan Tun Razak, KL) to know fully the origins of the Malays, the history of this country that you people become pendatang to, and try to appreciate that the "kiblat" or direction that you all should look to is this country Malaysia and the Gugusan Pulau Pulau Melayu of which Malaysia is part of, and not China or Taiwan.
You snort at RT's PhD. What qualification have you and which University - a Tongsan one?
How do like hearing a retort to your comment using your way of talking, Mister stupid?
Abido.
Am not finished yet, Mister stupid SMJK,
What the hell you talkin' about we having to learn Chinese to read the Chinese papers for? Where do you put your head - in between your legs?
This country is Malaysia. The Malays were even been prepared and had in fact put aside bahasa Jawi. And you now want us to learn Chinese? Despite Article 152 on BM? WTF.
See your unMalaysian, ultra kiasu and gangsterish thinking again - you talk about the Chinese press "scold at u or laughing at u..." You should have lived under a Mao Zedong regime where you would be paraded on the street, hands cuffed, shouted at and humiliated. Or in Fiji where the pendatang are even the majority, won the general elections but could not rule because the Army simply grabbed power and rule by military decrees.
Or in Thailand, Indonesia or the Philippines where you can't even use your own name let alone talk Chinese in the presence of the locals.
Now I'm done on you. Leaving at 1.00 AM, good riddance to you. You are not included in the group referred to in the earlier comments about mutual understanding and respect - not until you have read fully, understood and accepted the Constitution of this country.
i tot we were talking abt d malaysian spirit yet i kp seeing d word pendatang...not to say anythng but there are plenty of jokes abt malaysia...1 that is etch in my mind is: Malaysia exports talents and singapore imports them. Not to say anythng bt if our edu sys is based on merit im sure msia would improve greatly...ever wondered how a lone island like singapore can overtake msia in terms of progression in just 50yrs? Im nt complaining about d quota but instead of giving edu chances just to fill up the quota and leaving out many deserving students, why not figure out a better solution in order for msia to progres? "China says sichuan has been rebuilt after the earthquake bt msia is stil in the making after 50yrs... This jokes seriously shows how slow is msia progression...tats it for now.
Specially for SMJK 12:48am;
On a more serious note, what is there to be ashamed of with the awarding of Phd?
Are you still not brilliant enough to learn that even a former PM (so called statesman with the highest awarded salutation which so much better than a Phd) can still lie in his latest book after he infamously lied about DSAI black eye which he claimed as 'self-inflicted'?
What have you actually learned about racism in Malaysia? Even after the bloodied May 13th, 1969, are we any better than our nearest neighbour, the Singaporean? Have you realised that the Deputy PM of Singapore currently is a Singaporean?
Why must you considered yourself weak? Do you not have a political party that is championing for your own race? By the way, is it not the political parties are the representatives for you to voice your grievances? Are you trying to say that even after 50 years, the political parties are not effective in resolving the nation conflicts?
Specially for annonymous 1:00 am.
There is no need for you exclaim any stupidity here.
Only stupid people read stupid blog. Anyway, human being is known to be clever compared to animals.
However, to a certain degree, many are ignorant on many issues.
Therefore, actually there is no stupid questions when there are google translate and the ability to learn another language.
Perhaps, you could have inadvertently not able to read between the lines why the question was being asked.
Bear in mind, what is the purpose of this blog?
whoa....
I feel like bashing someone today...
Here I go..
SMJK,
You have thrown guite a remarkable incoherent rambling there.
I guess all those other Anons 12ish pm must be you (SMJK) as well.
you said:
______________________________
i saw someone asking why cant everyone be united under bahasa kebangsaan...one word to sum up what im thinking is-----LOL!
_______________________________
hahaha...LOL!?
That someone is me la...its obvious that you couldnt think of any better response...therefore ....LOL!!?
And yeah My response would be...LOL!
And more of his stupid comment:
_________________________________
Get your facts right before you talk out of your ass, 'Dr' Tee.
First of all, our command of the Malay language isn't as appalling as you claimed it is, ________________________________
OMG! hehe (yeah I am following your style of what you call as "butchering" a language)
Your head must be way up your f*cking ass that you couldnt even think properly let alone read properly what Dr Ridhuan has wrote and the facts that he has presented!
What part of "fact" that you dont understand? You cant read BM? Ohh sorry, you got A+... LOL. Here are facts of the "appalling" level of Chinese BM:
Malaysian Insider St Poll: 26.1% of chinese had almost no command or could not understand BM
NUTP survey; one in three vernacular school product cannot understand either English or BM and another one in three only understand a little bit.
If this is not appalling, then I dont know what "appalling" is!
This is the "facts" that Dr Ridhuan referred to...what about your fact???
Ohh..you have given them: "I got a freaking A+ in 2009 and most students in my year got an A or B, if that is any significance to you (Nevermind, I know it isn't)."
LOL! what a trivial fact! You yourself admit it later with "Fact is, we are somewhat weaker in verbal communication using BM due to a lack of consistent usage on a daily basis".
A bit of understatement there; "somewhat weaker". No...not somewhat weaker... Infact totally rubbish!
Yeah you are right there: your "fact" has no significance to us! and your BM A+ on paper has little or no value whatsoever!
Now let me give you my fact: more than 50% of chinese malaysian that I have conversed with, have a very very poor command and understanding of BM. Yeah it is my word against your word. This fact is just as credible as you fact.
Furthermore he said:
_________________________________
I'm sure we're well above the national school average.
However, we're certainly on par if not, far better in other aspects of the language including grammar and vocabulary, as exemplified by our SPM grades.
__________________________________
OMG! what sort of average are you talking about? On "par" with what?
Yeah..I am sure too...Average in comparison, and on par with the Pendatang Bangla and Pakistan. In fact i doubt so...these pendatangs would certainly be much better than you people had they have the same 50+ years exposure of being Malaysian!
To be continued...
Feel like long time no come in. Want to say to Anon 9.10 AM -
i oso tot we were talking abt d malaysian spirit yet i kp seeing pendatang defending vernacular schools, not accepting Malay Special Position like some have pointed out above. How man?
Now you pendatang say "not to say anythng but there are plenty of jokes abt malaysia.." Like dat not pendatang ha? Non-pendatang will defend and not laugh at people trying to make fun of their country, you know. You "transient" kind ha?
Don't talk about merit lah when you don't even accept Malay Special Position clearly spelt out in the Constitution, man.
Don't talk about Spore where they don't have democracy like speaking the way you speak, man. In Singapore, you'd be hauled up by Big Brother who'll scare the shit out of you for talking anything against the Gomen. Here you all naik kepala and talk about d malaysian spirit in a shit kind of way.
Hiyya bro ikhwan, I oso feel like bashing the ungrateful pendatang talk laik dat one.
A few quick ones for Anon 9:50 AM (same fellow as Anon 9.10 AM?) -
You would joke about this country yet would not take a joke by TDM about DSAI's black eye. Ada faham orang cakap "menyindir"? That's why you should have attended SK, man.
We should be avoiding the bloodied May 13th, 1969, but why r u asking "are we any better than our nearest neighbour, the Singaporean?" What has it got to do with anything except that you are a bloodied ultra kiasu?
Wat u trying to say by "Have you realised that the Deputy PM of Singapore currently is a Singaporean?" Sure la Dep PM of Spore is a Sporean, stooopid.
Talking about singapore, it has the Malay special right embedded right in its constitution. what happens to the Malay there now? The special right is just being rubbished for the sake of the pendatangs in singapore.
Anon 12:35 AM,
Show us the proof la Mister. Dont just say say only. Give names, where, when "malay without A in spm get into matriculation".
You dont even remember where, said "forget who saying malay yang cemerlang telah dihantar masuk ke matrikulasi.." Apa la lu? Mau bikin kacau sja ka? Cakap ikut suka sja ka? U go back to China la, see if you can talk laik dat one, komplen komplen govenment only.
Wat deserve u talk about? U people the richest community in the country, got so many twinning colleges, Universiti Tengku A Rahamn sommore, want more, more and more? No wonder they call your kind ultra kiasu.
U people with lots of money, many Chinese millionaires want to donate until UTAR refused RM30 million one Chinese millionaire wanted to donate last year, can find places also overseas, you want to deprive the Malays their chance, ha? Aiyoyo so kiasu u people.
You bloody lucky race, came here the British gave you all sorts of tongkat, became the richest, control the economy, the most in the professional field in the country, oso want the places meant for the Malays, ha?
U tink no Chinese oso do not work hard, karaoke, get drunk, gambling on the computer until parents want to commit suicide, ha?
I agree with you to choose only those Malay who really deserved n willing to study but when you say "dont make us keep laughing on u all", you are ultra kiasu again lah. If true Malaysian citizen, accept the Malay Special Position and the Malays left behind by British colonial policy etc, you shd be helping, advise, etc lah, not just keep laughing.
You people oso have the laughable kind, but how many comments you read Malays laughing at you? Only hitting at your ultra kiasuness, u realize that?
huhu...
Menyirap.
Bet he/she will not come back and read the responses, that coward ultra-kiasu.
Hoi Anonymous 9:57 AM
No understanding what you meaning. But wen you say "Only stupid people read stupid blog", dat's you, innit?.
Kiasu this and kiasu that. You know why Malaysia's not advancing as fast as our neighbours? Attitude like yours. Competition drives innovation, but of course people like you will never understand that statement. Whenever issues on racial equality and fairness arise, you and your merry gang of like-minded bigots such as RT and PERKASA will scream their heads off about special rights and protectionism.
Statistics? If you want to be pedantic, fine let's play it your way. Regarding SJKC dropouts, the actual article is available on AsiaoneNews, dated 2008. Wee Ka Siong ESTIMATED the number to be 25% which is exactly 1/4 and definitely not 1/3. RT is obviously exaggerating the numbers or he hadn't done his research properly, either way he still didn't get his facts correct. He also implied that Chinese teachers can't teach Malay well; statistics please? Malay only has 2 periods per week in vernacular schools; again, where's the data.
On your remark about our constitution. Article 152 states that the NATIONAL LANGUAGE is the Malay language, in no way does it refer to or imply a specific language used for day-to-day communication. On the contrary, it clearly states that 'everyone is free to teach, learn or use any other languages' and 'the Federal and State Governments are free to preserve or sustain the use and study of the language of any other community'.
Before giving me a lecture on our constitution, try reading it yourself first, instead of just blindly parroting skewed interpretations by bigoted individuals. Rational thoughts and analytical skills required, hope you're in possession of some.
And I definitely don't understand your rationale on the MARA/JPA issue. So according to you it's alright for Malays to get in touch with their roots by studying in Indonesia but ethnic Chinese students studying in China and Taiwan are bloody racists? Well, talk about being a hypocrite.
Nowhere did I mention anything about Chinese papers, but since you're being fussy with details... IF you want to read the Mandarin papers, go sign up for Mandarin classes. Notice the word 'if'? No one's forcing you to learn anything. Your comment on Article 152 is irrevelant in this context.
Ikhwan, no. The others are not me, try to notice the difference in sentence structures and writing style. Besides, would commenting under 2 different names serve me any purpose?
How credible is that NUTP survey? Is the methodology sound? The sample shows that 2/3 is weak in BM, what is the sample? Which school or schools? Does it accurately reflect the population when the data is extrapolated? This is akin to the analogy that "I observed that 2/3 Malays from Kampung X are lazy, therefore all Malays in the state are lazy". Don't like stereotypes? Neither do I.
You claimed that more than half of Malaysian Chinese have poor BM conversation skills. Now, this I do agree with you. I have already pointed this out in my previous post, YES we don't speak much BM daily. YES, most of our BM classes in school consist of mostly written lessons and not verbal lessons. And when one doesn't speak much, what do you expect? Perfect spoken BM with a Malay accent? Be realistic. The majority of us can converse perfectly fine and write just as well in BM.
Although here's a little anecdote that I find awfully embarassing. A Chinese girl in her mid-twenties boarded a public bus that I was in. She couldn't speak a word of BM at all and started talking to the driver, a Malay guy in Mandarin and some other dialects. Obviously the driver couldn't understand a word of what she's saying. In the end, some guy in front translated her words. That was the first time I ever saw such a ridiculous thing, maybe this is what you guys are talking about? Rest assured, even I am embarassed for her, and she definitely does not reflect the majority. (No stereotypes please!)
And no point arguing with you about my SPM grades and my schools grade. If you're in doubt that's fine, what do I have to gain by giving false grades? I might even snap a photo and upload my result slip if someone insists hard enough just for the sake of argument. Of course, we'll come back again to square one. "YOUR BM A+ BUT YOU CAN'T SPEAK MALAY!" "CHINESE GET A ONLY BY MEMORIZING, NO CREATIVITY AT ALL" "ULTRA-KIASU, WHY SO MANY As??" "YOU GOT A, OKAY, BUT SCHOLARSHIPS ARE STILL OUR SPECIAL RIGHT".
About Singapore's democracy, so we have a slightly more freedom in our media, is it something to be proud of? We're nowhere near the top in the Press Freedom Index (statistics again!). What about the many other aspects that we're inferior to Singapore?
Oh and, 'Mister Stupid', seriously? Horrible comeback, try harder.
YOUR BM A+ BUT YOU CAN'T SPEAK MALAY!" "CHINESE GET A ONLY BY MEMORIZING"
Idk wth are you people memorizing about?Memorizing BM or memorizing SJ=History??If u said that Chinese get A in BM because they are memorizing BM that's mean YOU ARE MEMORIZING SOALAN BOCOR! Kamu sudah menipu!Tidak jujur!
to anon 2.52pm
have u jst noticed wat u said? Your words are insulting two parties..one is the chinese(which u meant to do anyway) and another is Kementerian pelajaran. If the questions are leaked that means that the kementerian ppl arent doing their job properly am i right? Think before you speak or in this instance comment.
o n i think you dont understand what smjk is talking about...i wont bother explaining to you since his meaning is so clear yet you stil dont und...so just buzz off...
The Constitution says
"no person shall be prohibited or prevented from using (otherwise than for official purposes), or from teaching or learning, any other language"
The key words are "otherwise than for official purposes".
It means no one shall be prevented from using other languages EXCEPT FOR OFFICIAL PURPOSES.
Medium of instruction in schools is for official purposes. So Mandarin and Tamil cannot be medium of instruction in schools.
It means other languages can be used or learnt in schools but not as medium of instruction because that is official purpose and must be BM.
The fact that Chinese schools have existed for over 50 years does not mean it's right.
We need a strong leader to implement single-stream schooling or SSS now, not dilly dally with the words "when the rakyat wants it" like Najib said in his blog.
Pls excuse my testing out as my comment has disappeared despite sevral times submitting it.
"If the questions are leaked that means that the kementerian ppl arent doing their job properly am i right?"
Cheh,u accuse the kementerian.Yes i admit they aren't do their job properly because they got bribe from RICH people.Siapa makan cili,dia terasa pedas.
I bet u,not only the huge exam bro,small2 exam lagi BOCOR soalan peperiksaan itu.Dia rasuah kerani-kerani sekolah.
Anyway,u can judge my statement whether it's true or not.Kepada pelajar-pelajar yang melihat komen di blog ini, just look aroud yourself who are the top one race that has been caught for copying in exam.For me,aku sudah ada pengalaman itu.
uiks...I thought of preparing a response to SMJK previous comments however it seems that his/her latest comments were a lot more "hilarious" and down right ridiculous so let me response to this latest one.
SMJK,
You said:
_________________________________
How credible is that NUTP survey? Is the methodology sound? The sample shows that 2/3 is weak in BM, what is the sample?
__________________________________
huhu...you want to throw in doubt to the source of the fact ke? Looks clever but not to the people with technical or statistical knowledge what about the credibility of your fact? This study from NUTP was based on the survey of 159 school. Based on my calculation, this sampling size results in more than 90% confidence level and with less than 5% margin of error!
Can you comprehend that? Yes? No? whatever...for other readers, this indicate that in simple terms, there is ~90% chance that for the whole population of chinese Malaysian, 1/3 know nothing and another 1/3 no little of BM! And yes combination of this appalling results indicate that 60% of your people has a very poor level of BM!
Which interestingly coincide with my own observation of you people as I mentioned above.
And yeah what about yours fact? Nil confident level? Nil Margin of error? What numbers of sampling did you used?
More from SMJK:
__________________________________
"I observed that 2/3 Malays from Kampung X are lazy, therefore all Malays in the state are lazy". Don't like stereotypes? Neither do I.
__________________________________
My comment:
Be steoreotype however you like! Who cares? You missed the whole point! When we talk about the appalling level of BM among the chinese, what we meant is the majority of the chinese or significant portion of the chinese! Of course la we know that not all chinese is like that!
Evidence is right in front of our eyes, See Dr Ridhuan himself...he is a chinese that has better BM than even a Malay like me!!
So mate, for god sake, please dont try to steer this debate away in unrelated direction and dont cloud the point of this whole discussion!
You are either truly stupid or pretend to be stupid. Whatever it is...I think you are stupid!
When we said that african is poor does that mean that all african is poor? when we say Singaporean being rich does that mean we are saying that all Singaporeans are rich? Nobody poor? What? Still cannot comprehend?
More of SMJK whining:
________________________________
And when one doesn't speak much, what do you expect? Perfect spoken BM with a Malay accent? Be realistic. The majority of us can converse perfectly fine and write just as well in BM.
___________________________________
Huh...why are you throwing this question to me? You know the problem at hand...so why dont you fixed it! If the problem arises because you people dont speak much of BM...then speak much la...I thought you people are the smart one...takkan itu pun aku nak ajar!??
What do I expect? fluent BM as the Malay? Yes indeed...
I expect you to have an acceptable level of BM fluency just like how I am expected to have fluency in English here in Australia (and I am not even Australian citizen!). In fact after more than 50+ years of merdeka....you are expected to be as fluent as Malay!
You people are the smart one! Takkan ini pun tak boleh buat? I have seen you people and other races, within one generation, they speak impeccable English just like the English people speak it. How many generations have you people been in this beloved Tanah Melayu!!!???
To be continued.....
Continue from above
SMJK wrote:
__________________________________
......And no point arguing with you about my SPM grades and my schools grade. If you're in doubt that's fine, what do I have to gain by giving false grades? I might even snap a photo and upload my result slip if someone insists hard enough just for the sake of argument.
___________________________________
My comment:
No thanks...you can keep your useless A+ paper in your dusty display shelves or frame or whatever!
Who's arguing with you about your or your friends A+ in BM??? Not me for sure!
Again you completely missed my point! who gives a damn whether you got an A+ or A+++ in BM when in reality you could not put them in use at that supposedly "A" level as reflected by your paper!!?? No difference to an F for me!
Would it be acceptable for an engineer who got A++ in his/her thermodynamic subject, designing a faulty building air conditioning systems that doesnt deliver sufficient coolness to the building!? Yeah dont concern yourself with practical issue as long as on exam paper you did well!!
Would it be acceptable for a shower system that doesnt deliver sufficient water just because the hydraulic engineers in practical couldnt perform a proper hydraulic calculation eventhough he got A+++++ in his hydraulic subject exam!!??
What??? Acceptable like you in "BM" case?? Not acceptable?
Is this your logic!!?? "Oh I cant really speak fluent BM but I got A+ in BM exam!! bla bla bla"
"Sigh"....
That is the most sick excuse I have ever heard.
It is the epitome of your ultrakiasu attitude!
You and Your people never has any fault and never admit any....Not even when the facts has been clearly presented and not even when you, yourself realized the fault at hand.
My comment countering SMJK keeps disappearing. It appears to be Blogger.com problem. Otherwise some ultra kiasu in the corner somewhere, haha. Will try another time. SMJK now has a reprieve!
ikhwan,
Agree with you. It appears that I can submit only short comments for now. So, I'll just echo what you say against SJMK for the time being.
Ikhwan
I have already stated my stand lots of times. There is no doubt that there are Chinese students with poor command of BM. But still it is incorrect to say that 2/3 of all Chinese are poor in BM.
China Press gave the total number of SJKC schools in the country to be 1291. Given the population and sample size of 159, my calculations show that the sample of 159 is still far less than 224 required for a 90% confidence level with 5% margin of error.
Numbers aside, students in SJKC schools are not a truly random distribution. I would say the methodology is still flawed. Geographical location, family background and other factors do affect a student's linguistic abilities. Some SJKC schools perform better and some less, same goes for SK schools. You can't just nitpick a few schools and extrapolate the results to generalize all SJKC students.
Obviously we're going nowhere in this argument. You'll definitely continue with your argument that the majority of Chinese in this country has horrible BM. To put it this way, SJKC schools can also provide an good learning platform for the BM language, given that the students are interested in learning of course. Students who aren't serious about an education, even if they do enroll in an SK school won't show any improvement in BM or English and Mandarin for that matter.
I believe it is not the SJKC school system at fault, but in fact the attitude of some SJKC students (or even SK too). Put a good student anywhere and he can still excel.
Ikhwan
Of course I am well aware that grades are not everything, but since someone questioned the truthfulness of my statements I must at least give a reply out of courtesy, no?
And so here we go again about SPM. The BM paper only measures our ability to write essays, and answer some literature and grammar questions. It is definitely not a thorough assessment of a student's BM. But given our results and the fact that SPM is a standardized examination, proves that we do have a certain level of command of the language.
Aiseh SMJK
What??? What sort of sampling methodology are you using? We can compare our calculation and method if you want!
What is with "students in SJKC schools are not a truly random distribution" got to do with the reliability of the results (in statistical terms)!?
Did you get A+ in your math & statistic?? It looks like another useless A+ (If you got that) as with your BM paper!
Dude, FYI, Whether the sample is in form of "random distribution" or not is not the issue. What make sense, is that for a statistical result reliability, one have to choose the sample randomly! Can you see the difference there??
And of course, for the whole terms "confidence level, margin of error etc" to hold true given that typical methodology that we normally used to calculate such a thing, the sample itself has to be normally or Gaussian distributed. This is perhaps a good assumption as in the case of many other natural phenomena.
And I find it interesting to read your last statement:
_________________________________
"I believe it is not the SJKC school system at fault, but in fact the attitude of some SJKC students (or even SK too). Put a good student anywhere and he can still excel.
__________________________________
My comment:
hmm...so SJKC is not at fault eh? Whatever....now going with your own logic then....if SJKC is not at fault and a good student can excel anywhere he/she is put at....so the fact that 2/3 of SJKC student at that 159 schools (for argument sake) having an appalling level of BM must means that those students (which mainly comprises of Cina) are not a "good" stock then!!
@SMJK
Wanna know my point of view? For me the existence of SJK is one of the root of racial problems here in Malaysia.
Everything starts there. Since you people only mingle with your kind, it's only natural when you grow up you're gonna accustomed to that way of living.
Well maybe not you, but I'm talking about the rest of you. Don't tell me this doesn't make sense. You know it.
p/s : the Chinese people who keen to steer away from other race (supposedly) because they have trouble in communication.
Who's to blame? Who shape the Chinese people as we see nowadays? Use your brain to think. The answer's within you.
Agree with you and support your views, Ginosaji.
My stinking comment to counter his stinking one still keep disappearing. Ada hantu lah, kawan. But I will also echo you in the meanwhile.
SMJK,
Cuba jawap soalan-soalan dibawah dalam BM:
1.Kenapa di negara barat seperti Australia, Amerika tiada sekolah vernakular? Cuba jawap secara jujur.
2.Mengapa sekolah vernakular harus anda pertahankan?
Saya tidak mahu mendengar alasan tentang kualiti kerana sebagai rakyat Malaysia, anda dan golongan pendidik anda juga bertanggungjawab menambahbaik kualiti sekolah sedia ada.
3.Tidakkah agenda nasional lebih penting dari agenda kaum dalam soal pendidikan?
Tolong jangan gunakan pendekatan 'ignore, divert and downplay'.
"I believe it is not the SJKC school system at fault, but in fact the attitude of some SJKC students (or even SK too). Put a good student anywhere and he can still excel."
Kalau ini alasannya, mengapa anda masih perlukan sekolah vernakular?
mlsala kena asyik comment ttg perkara yg jelas di d'pan mata...gaduh kt sni pn tiada faedahnya...korang yg msih mau pertikaikn standard sjk n sk ckplah kt surat khabar...bdk aus makin ckp makin x munasabah...
Those who keep defending Chinese schools, arguing figures, location etc like SMJK, should read and re-read Article 152 of the Constitution. Must try and understand the meaning of the words "(otherwise than for official purposes)" like Anon 5.10 PM said above.
Go check with the experts to know that it means only BM shall be used for official purposes. And schools are official purposes. Therefore Mandarin cannot be used as a medium of instruction in schools.
For goodness sake, such people also must know and realize that no one is stopping the use of, teaching and the learning of Mandarin in schools. But that it must be as an elective subject and not as a medium of instruction.
SMJK has all along been trying to justify the existence of Chinese schools. He should state where his kiblat is. For his information, kiblat is the direction Muslims pray to i.e Mecca. Of course, he must know nobody asks non-Muslims to follow that. But it means they should state which direction they have their feelings for - this country or where else.
Anon 10:12pm
Aiyoyo....nak pertikaikan standard sjk and sk sila cakap kat surat khabar? Nak buat apa? Orang lain macam Dr Ridhuan dah buat lah brader!
Ni artikel yang dipost diblog ni buat pengetahuan saudara, disiarkan di akhbar Sinar Harian. Tak baca ke? Jangan baca Nanyang Siang Pau je...
Jangan jadi pengecut! chicken!
Jangan hanya cakap "budak aus cakap makin xmunasabah" tunjukkanlah apa yang tak munasabahnya supaya boleh dibawa berbincang atau berdebat.
bercakap pasal tamadun china, bagi saya dari segi kebendaan ia terlalu tinggi.
Ia terlalu dan tersangat rendah dari segi kemanusiaan.
Rakyat mereka tak bebas, termasuk dalam mencari harta. Rakyat tidak boleh memiliki harta melebigi dari sara diri.
Demikian juga dari segi keluarga. Mereka tidak dibenar memilki anak melebih dari seorang.
Jika lebih anak itu akan diambil oleh kerajaan dan dijual untuk mendapatkan hasil kerajaan.
Jika soal kemanusiaan terlalu rendah, bermakna tamadun china tidak boleh dianggap tinggi.
"I believe it is not the SJKC school system at fault, but in fact the attitude of some SJKC students (or even SK too). Put a good student anywhere and he can still excel."
Twisted logic
SJKC is a breeding pool for probably soon to be chauvanist kiasu.
It's like the Dengue that are caused by the Aedes. So to prevent the dengue, do you kill the aedes? sure not, it's a wasteful effort. instead you opt for removing their 'breeding pool'. kasi buang semua bekas yang boleh biak jentik2, yang degil kasi taruk garam ubat.
Now I want to continue refuting SMJK utterly absurd allegations.
SMJK wrote:
__________________________________
Whenever issues on racial equality and fairness arise, you and your merry gang of like-minded bigots such as RT and PERKASA will scream their heads off about special rights and protectionism.
_______________________________
My response:
Wow, It is very convenient isn’t it for you to label “bigots” to RT and Perkasa when the real bigots is actually people like you, Dong Zong, other Zong, DAP, MCA and Wee Ka Siong!
Let us talk about what is actually equality? Equal as defined mathematically as being the same or identical in value. Now, given this definition, would a 50/50 split between Pribumi and NONS on the aspects of economies, education etc resulted in equality. Well it would if the composition of Pribumi and the NONS is also 50/50??!. But this is not the case isnt it?!
There is a mathematical concept called “weighted value”. Let consider a population of a 1000 with composition of 650 Pribumi and 350 Nons (which mimic the composition of races in our country). If we split the quota at 50/50 (so as to be equal as perceived by you ultrakiasu people) say for a 100 available public university intake. What weighted value could we get under such arrangement? It is 50/650 Pribumi v.s. 50/350 Nons which is ~8% of Pribumi and 14% of Nons respectively getting into public university. How can 8% v.s. 14% being equal? Is this the racial equality that you people has been shouting about??! Any persons with basic level of maths would not have called this equality!!!
Do you want to look at pure figure? Ok let us look at this angle; how many people that doesn’t get into the public uni as a result of your “equality” concept? ….Well it is 600 Pribumi v.s. only 300 Nons in this case. Is this equality?
“Sigh”
If this is what you people call as equality, then I guess you would be better off in South Africa back at the time when they are still practicing the apartheid. This (the equality as per ultrakiasu) has the exact detrimental consequences in comparison to the S.A apartheid practices!
Now with this terms “Special Rights”. Yes, the constitution clearly said about the special rights of the Pribumi……however tell me what is so special for these people (the Pribumi) when they only asked for a 30% economic quota and 60% education quota in comparison to their numbers that comprises of ~65% of this nation population!!?
Yeah..What is so “special” about that? What? That is damn right…it is not special at all! Infact It is fair and equal! So why on earth would you people keep on whining and harping of being unjustly treated, subjected with unthinkable discrimination (yeah folk…this one is downright hilarious) etc etc!!??
There should have not been any fuss about this at all. It is a fuss, because you and your people mind has been so polluted by the DAP propaganda. It is a fuss because you and your people being greedy, tamak haloba and ULTRAKIASU!
It is true BM proficiency among the Chinese was unsatisfactory.
Why? This is because the government had failed to give enough emphasis to assist those who were weak in the language to boost their skills in the national schools.
This is because the learning of the language is not really enhanced in both the primary and secondary levels.
Obviously, there will be critics blaming the vernacular schools but because even there, BM is a compulsory subject and after that, they go to secondary school where BM is even more prominent.
There is just no proper programme in place to help these Chinese primary school students to adopt when in the secondary level.
Of course I fully agree that every Malaysian should master the language, especially the younger generation, but when it comes to integration, there are many other pertinent factors involved.
There are also government policies where every Malaysian wants to have a place here, to be treated equally.
Of course language is important because it enhances communication between all the races but still, it is the policies of the government that truly help to promote integration.
Prof Johan Saravanamuttu reported that Malaysia's human rights practice, by way of national laws and legal instruments, has steadily slid downhill since independence in 1957.
This is due to several major political developments since independence and particularly because of the actions of the government led by Dr. Mahathir Mohamad since 1981.
The only positive actions on the part of the state in recent years has been the endorsement of several international human rights conventions and the setting up of a national commission on human rights.
The actions on the part of the state in weakening human rights practice in the country can be stated as follows:
The steady erosion of constitutional provisions for human rights and fundamental liberties such as the right to life and liberty of the person, protection against slavery forced labor, equality before the law, freedom of movement, speech, expression, assembly and association, including the right to strike and take industrial action (Articles 5, 6, 8, 9, 10(1)(a) (b) (c), freedom of religion, right to education and property (Articles 11, 12, 13).
The most cynical developments occurred in the Mahathir period when the principle of judicial review (Article 121) was virtually debunked after the sacking of the Lord President and two Supreme Court judges in 1988.
Elimination of the right to seek the writ of habeas corpus, whereby preventive detention cannot be challenged in court, since the 1988/89 amendments to the Internal Security Act (1960).
The increasing centralization of the powers of government in the hands of the executive branch and the steady debunking of the principle of the separation of powers of the legislature and judiciary as provided for in the 1957 Constitution.
This was accomplished along with the steady removal of checks and balances in the system via various constitutional procedures and amendments aimed at reducing local state power, abolition of elected local governments and eroding of the symbolic as well as the legal role of the Rulers. (Lee, 1995)
Anon 11.21
another "ignore, divert and downplay'".
Stick to the topic lah...
Islam considers all humans the same as it makes no distinction between one group and another.
This is evident in Surah an-Nahl 16:90, that “Allah has enjoined justice and righteousness.”
In addition, Islam is based on principles which are accommodative, just, fair, and responsible towards everyone in the society regardless of race, background and religious belief.
The minority groups have the right to partake in the development of the country in terms of political, economic, social, educational, and religious activities.
In addition, historical evidence stands firmly to show that the non-Muslims were treated well and protected under covenants in States governed predominantly by Muslims especially during the governance of Prophet Muhammad S.A.W.
In the same vein, one may also witness the same peaceful co-existence of both the majority and the minority groups in Malaysia.
Everybody must maintain cordial inter-racial relations. We can reap bountiful benefits from racial harmony in the country. Only then will disunity be removed, and we can rest assured that we will move in the era of globalisation with great alacrity.
Our diversity mould us into who we are. Though we may echo idiosyncratically, we tone at the same chord of harmonization.
We, as Malaysians, should live and dream as Malaysians!
“ the attitude of some SJKC students” SMJK said? Can he tell us how many of those from SMJK would stick to and keep defending Chinese schools? How has that “attitude” helped in the creation of a united Malaysia?
How can the so-called “muli-nations within a nation” that the Dong Zong spoke about help in bringing about a united Malaysia? Do they not realize that even liberal Western countries like UK have said, “muti-culturalism is dead”. Spoken by no less than the British PM David Cameron, echoed by the German Chancellor Angela Merkel, and two other leaders of the EU.
Has the SJMK fellow anything to say about that? He has not said anything about that as far as I can see. Or he chooses to say only the convenient things for him to say?
Clearly Mister SMJK 1:52 PM doesn’t like to be called kiasu. Yet he doesn’t argue his case out. For example, try to explain his perception or interpretation of the word kiasu and explain how he or any Chinese like him is not kiasu. Come on la, the fact that there is such a word kiasu means that there must be kiasus among them.Why grumble “Kiasu this and kiasu that”? The fact that he doesn’t explain kiasu-ism, yet accuse people a lot, shows he is kiasu, correct?
And he says “why Malaysia's not advancing as fast as our neighbours” is because of “Attitude like yours”. What an argument. What “Competition drives innovation” is he talking about when there is no level playing field to even talk about competition? Competition under those circumstances will mean only win, win, win situation. Only for him and his likes. Got meaning? Where got? Kiasu thinking? You answer.
But of course he’ll say “people like you will never understand that statement.” That’s kiasu logic, no less.
And why can’t “Whenever issues on racial equality and fairness arise”, we or Perkasa "scream about special rights and protectionism"? When you and your kind don’t respect or accept the Special Position of the Malays and the Bumiputeras of Sabah and Sarawak?
And you argue whether it’s 1/3 or ¼ SJKC dropouts. What difference does it make when, substantively, the percentage of dropouts either way there is “substantial”? Where got good preparation in SRJKC compared to SRK, when the kids can also benefit in exchanging a few words in BM daily with pupils of other races in SRK?
Anon 10:49 AM,
Poor BM in Chinese schools because no practice talking BM like in SK and lower syllabus and standard of pass lah. No mixing with others except their own kind lah.
Pls get your perspective right, friend.
Anon 11:21 AM,
Who is Prof Johan Saravanamuttu? Haven't heard of him.
And why you talking about Malaysia's human rights here when people are talking something else?
Why don't you read about the US practice of detention without trial in Guantanamo Bay, that justifies Malaysia ISA?
Aiyyo Anon 11:52 AM,
Anywhere or anything that shows that when others do things bad to us, we should just keep quiet?
Even the Christians, one of whose teachings is when some one slaps you on one cheek, turn the other cheek, don't do that any more. Now want to use Kalimah Allah sommore.
People hog the chauvinist, racist and subversive slogan Malaysian Malaysia without acknowledging the Special Position of the Malays and the Bumiputeras of Sabah and Sarawak, and want the Bumi equity target be aabolished, Malays/ Muslims to keep quiet ka?
Where got logic. Where got fair.
True, Everybody must maintain cordial inter-racial relations. But you must preach to the others also lah. Or are you a Christian sounding Muslim?
Wah there are so many Cik Ainon here including me haha.SMJK,Ikwan, you are brave but not for the Cik AinonS here.
Alamak bro Ainon 1:43 PM,
Me too lah.
But non-Ainons no bravery one, unless like Tun Dr Mahathir, Dr Ridhuan Tee and only a very few others who declare themselves fully, give full names, place of work, etc.
Not difficult to refer. Just type Anon, c & p the time, and type away.
After all many blogging names are oso not easy to remember.
As the old A.R Badul joke says, asalkan "hati mau baik, be...". Only God knows hati many of us bloggers.
btw, non-blog owning only commenting oso called bloggers, no?
abdullahngah @ 9:37 AM,
Diorang kata dari segi kerohanian pun diorang tinggi. Kebanyakan Cina sejak beribu tahun praktikkan unsur unsur tiga agama - Confucianism, Taoism dan Buddhism - tiga tiga sekali gus, 3-in-1. Ada ditulis didalam buku sejarah.
Fikirlah, diorang boleh dapat syurga dari segi tiga agama.
Saya tak tahu sama ada itu pendirian materialistik ke tidak.
Saya tahu hanya yang kiasu mahu semua apa saja kalau boleh.
According to Datuk Dr. Zainal Aznam Yusof (deceased), an economist and policy consultant, just before his death, he wrote that although power corrupts, it is a universal rule that no one gives up power willingly (for example, Mubarak in Egypt).
However, the longer those in power cling to their posts, the greater the lure of corruption.
All holders of power, especially autocrats and dictators, tend to see themselves as indispensable.
One way is to amend the constitution, or pass a separate law, that limits the tenure of power holders for a fixed period; but this is not foolproof; that is still the direction that Malaysia should take.
If there is a much shorter tenure, maybe violence will cease to be an option to change leadership that has outlived its usefulness.
From the rulers to the ruled, from the legislators to the enforcers, the rule of law must prevail.
If conflict is part of the natural order, and if it unavoidable, then efforts must be made to mitigate its impact, spread and duration.
Sustained, inclusive and environmentally friendly economic growth and good governance can do their part, but they have their limits.
Anon 2:21 PM looks the same as the 11:21 AM fler,
Same type, orang bincang lain, dia cakap lain. Tak ada kaitkan pun dengan tajuk atau isi pos RT ini.
Cakap pasal pinda Perlembagaan lah buat undang undang baru lah pulak mengarut dia.
Dia tak peduli apa orang cakap. Jenis ultra kiasu juga nih. Marah pulak bila dikata ultra kiasu.
Jangan pedulikan dia, folks. Biar dia syiok sendiri.
Actually I remembered Datuk Dr. Zainal had written an article in the Edge somewhere in February 2011.
In the article he wrote that many countries have a long history of many conflicts and they can recur.
The May 1969 racial riot in Malaysia were actually seminal conflicts. And there is nothing now to show that we are still immune from racial conflicts; they are just shimmering below the surface.
He quoted examples of the burning of churches and temples, the insulting behaviour towards sensitive religious symbols, the lack of sensitivity to sensitive-load words, the unhappiness over opaque religious conversions, the demarcation of of the powers of the syariah and civil courts, and the insults to historical experiences which are just disguised and quasi-forms of suppressed conflicts.
The ethnic fragmentation and polarisation have actually become endemic and pervasive, and they are fertilisers for conflicts.
He also noted that we are also not short of irresponsible politicians who stir and stoke the sensitive parts of the national psyche, thus edging people towards conflicts and acting as paid handmaidens of violence.
Furthermore, the template for politicians in ethnically diverse societies like ours is to generate animosities (and exploit ethnic insecurities and deep seated prejudices) and conflicts is well established.
There are just no clear and effective counter-measures to check these politicians on both sides of the political divide. The arsenal of conflict-enhancing behaviour is alive and well.
According to him that even after more than 50 years of independent growth, we are no closer to being racially blind.
Food, shelter, security, economic opportunties and fairness are necessary conditions for blunting ethnic conflicts, but they are not sufficient.
Economic growth, according to him, so far, has not really helped inter-ethnic integration. While the poor are still with us, their size has been reduced.
The current and future conflicts in Malaysia will be fueled more by an outraged sense of inequality and unfairness in economic opportunities, and by dangerous politicians on both sides of the political divide.
abc
Anonymous 10.49
Kerajaan yang anda maksudkan adalah kerajaan campuran UMNO,MCA, MIC. Dr awal2 lg, MCA dan MIC menghendaki sekolah vernakular.
Jangan cuba berdolak-dalik seolah2 cuba meletakkan semua kesalahan pada UMNO.
Sepatutnya UMNO dari awal bertegas dalam hal2 sebegini. Tidaklah selepas 50 thn merdeka kita masih lagi menghadapi masalah penyatuan kaum.
Inilah sikap ultrakiasu yang tidak boleh diterima. Meletakkan kesalahan pada bahu orang lain semata2 dan terlalu berdolak-dalik semata2 bagi mempertahankan kepentingan mereka. Mereka harus sedar dari sindrom penafian dan berhenti bersikap seperti 'bangau oh bangau'.
tak lama lagi, u kat sini jadi cam u kat bangladesh, diploma sama tarf je ngan spm gred 3 kat sini, kuantiti x melambangkan kualiti, saya ada tulis pasal forum perdana, khas untuk ustaz ridhuan...
Hakmi
Universiti apa tu? UTAR? Univ. Lim Kok Wing?
Cuba terangkan lebih mendalam sikit.
Kepada yang lain;
Disini ada blog blog yang membincangkan tentang hal pemberian biasiswa. Saya fikir elok untuk kita semua baca termasuk yang ultrakiasu tu...
http://eddydaud.blogspot.com/2011/05/jpa-scholarshipsit-is-not-as-simple-as.html
http://kennvoices.blogspot.com/2011/05/se-simple-abc.html
ikhwan,
Hahaha "Universiti" Lim Kok Wing, hahaha.
Tun Mahathir kata dulu dia benarkan taraf Kolej saja. Untuk graphic arts dan sebagainya.
Lim Kok Wing sendiri dulu cartoonist di New Straits Times. Kartun dia nama Gulu Guli. Tak tahulah dia kartun lagi ke tidak.
Kerajaan sekarang lemah macam pondan. Lembik. Murah hati tak bertempat. Berlembut nak tarik undi.
Nanti menang sorak negara tergadai kita ramai2 cari "orang2" yg bertanggungjawab tu.
Ye kalau nak senang ckp "cakap senang buat susah". Tapi benda ni jadi susah pasal mula2 dah buat dia jadi susah. Sama rata = adil. Apekejadah? Adakah sama rata sama rasa tu adil, dan adakah adil = semua sama?
Kepada bangsat2 yang cuba memanipulasikan perkataan "adil", sini aku ajar.
Adil = meletakkan sesuatu pada tempatnya.
Tu je. Tapi maksud mendalam. Tak semestinya sama rata sama rasa tu adil.
Bengap sangat otak sampai tak boleh fikir? Aku rasa orang2 ni saja buat tak faham. Nanti bila dah kena hentam terus tukar topik.
"Are you ready to be a martyr in the flag of democracy"?
-by becoming leaders you people are bound to this sentence. So leader of Malaysia, we want a CHANGE of system but NOT a change of party!
Our so-called leaders, do your job properly. Yes, we mean PROPERLY.
Don't let karma return the favor from your misleading deeds.
Ginosaji
Tak boleh sama rata sama rasa. Sebab ada Kedudukan Istimewa Melayu dan Bumiputera Sabah dan Sarawak.
Tun Dr Mahathir dah cakap begitu. Aku setuju. Kalau tak, apa gunanya ada Perkara 153 Perlembagaan. Kalu tak, apa gunanya Perlembagaan.
Mesti ada Perlembagaan. Perkara perkara penting seperti Kedudukan Istimewa Melayu tak boleh pinda. Dilindung Akta Hasutan. Siapa tak suka boleh angkat kaki.
Anon 11.37am;
Itu Tun Mahathir punya kata mana boleh pakai punya.
Dulu dia kata akan pegang tampok pimpinan selagi rakyat tidak memulaunya.
Kemudian, tiba2 tahun 2002, dia kata nak undur. Bukan rakyat yang kecoh tapi majlis tertinggi UMNO yang lompat sehingga seorang menteri punya tumit kasut patah.
Dari dulu sampai terkeluar buku yang ditulisnya, mana boleh percaya dia punya kata2 lagi?
"seorang menteri kanan beragama Kristian sanggup berkata, “apa salahnya Kristian menjadi Perdana Menteri” -
Memang tidak salah dari segi Perlembagaan. Tapi salah dari segi suasana sosial dinegara ini, memandang kapada
1. Islam agama negara ini
2. Majoriti penduduk adalah Muslim
3. Sejak 54 tahun lalu PM adalah orang Islam
4. Kita mahukan harmoni dan aman selama lamanya. Banyak Muslim tidak senang hati jika keadaan dimana PM orang Islam ditukar menjadi PM orang Kristian.
Saya mahu tanya pulak:
Boleh kah Pakiam jadi Pope di Vatican?
Apa salahnya Kristian kulit hitam ke kulit kuning ke kulit coklat ke jadi Pope?
Ultra kiasu tidak akan selesai dengan menohmah UMNO, BN, Kerajaan, Melayu, Islam dan sebagainya. Itu lah modal mereka. Itulah pendirian mereka.
Jika mereka berhenti berbuat demikian, bermakna mereka kehabisan modal, tidak ada modal lagi untuk berpolotik atau tak ada cara lagi untuk memajukan kepentingan mereka.
Kita perlu terus membidas mereka. Tak usah harapkan mereka sedar. Hanya harapkan yang tak ultra kiasu, mungkin sediikit sahaja kiasunya, sedar. Sedarkan tanggungjawab mereka kapada Perlembagaan negara. Sedarkan baha kiblat mereka adalah megara ini Malaysia. Tidak lain, tidak bukan.
Ultra kiasu mesti tinggalkan budaya kongsi gelap, penjahat dan gengster. Itu institusi yang sngat merosakkan akhlak anak muda dan mencemar nama bangsa Cina dimerata dunia. Sebab ada dipraktikkan disetiap Chinatown dimana mana kota antarabangsa. Sehingga diEropah menyebabkan PM Britain berkata "multi-culturalism is dead". Di ikuti Chanselor German dan pemimpin dua lagi negara EU. Britain sudah mula memburu mereka direstoran restoran Cina dikota kota UK.
Benar, gengster dan mahia juga ada dikalangan penduduk berasal dari Itali dan Russia (Italian and Russian mafia) di Amerika dan Eropah. Tetapi mereka tidak ada Chinatown disetiap bandar besar serupa kaum Cina.
Gejala Chinatown itu sendiri menjadi bukti kuat keultra kiasuan kaum Cina. Malaysia ada Chinatown merata rata. Selagi ada apa yang kadang kadang dipanggil "ghetto mentality" seperti itu, selagi itu susah timbul pemikiran terbuka, mahu bercamour luas, mahu berkiblatkan kapada bumi yang dipijak.
Institusi kongsi gelap, penjahat dan gengster ini dikatakan timbul diabad 19 dinegeri China, dengan cubaan melawan usaha usaha Kuasa Barat British, Germany dll cuba menawan atau menjelajah negeri China. Tetapi diMalaysia mereka tidak sebegitu hebat melawan penjajah British. Hanya Chin Peng dan Parti Komininis cuba membuatnya. Tetapi hanya selepas Perang Dunia Kedua, dipertengahan abad 20, tidak sebelomnya.
Aneh sekali pendirian kongsi gelap, penjahat dan gengster ini. Nampaknya mereka buat apa saja untuk mencapai maksud dan tujuan mereka. Itu yang menyebabkan dan dinamakan ultra kiasu.
So'alnya, apa kah gejala kongsi gelap, penjahat dan gengster itu sudah menjadi budaya orang Cina?
Dear Anonymous 8:23am ,
Saya ingin memperbetulkan anggapan ultra kiasu yang selalu tidak sehaluan dengan UMNO mahupun BN.
Let us not be complicated. All of us know that this nation of ours is rich with plenty of resources. Many of us are not interested to manage the resources nor govern the country.
Therefore, when there are people willing to represent us in governing and manage the nation, we vote them into the office.
Now, for the understanding of many, we all agree that those elected are to manage the resources of the country to pay their salary, allowances, office, transportation, office and house. Any additional resources is to distribute to the Rakyat. If not enough, then the Rakyat will help.
Are the resources such as petrol, rubber, oil palm, mining, permits, etc not enough for those governing the country?
Rakyat pay taxes basing on whatever they earn in the country.
Rakyat pays excise duties and taxes to purchase cars and also government charges for registration and taxes to finance the vehicles.
Even though Rakyat do not pay road tax for using motorbike (last time is RM2 per year), every new bike will be taxed at least RM1,000!
Rakyat pays tax when they go for movies. Even watching Astro, apart from paying the monthly dues, subscribers pay 6% tax per bill.
Rakyat also pays taxes for making telephone calls.
Rakyat pays 6% tax when eating at restaurants.
Apart from taxes, Rakyat also pays for the increase in the prices for flour, sugar, vegetables, and other food because to help those to govern the nation.
If the current government for the past 50 years can't even manage the rich resources well and then with the Rakyat have to continue to help to pay even for the basics such as medical and education, do you still consider all these as ultra kiasu?
What about the other ills, corruption, abuse of power, funds missing, close tenders, etc?
Dear Anonymous 11:58 AM,
I don't understand you para
"If the current government for the past 50 years can't even manage the rich resources well and then with the Rakyat have to continue to help to pay even for the basics such as medical and education, do you still consider all these as ultra kiasu?"
Not clear what you mean by "all these" - you mean the current government or those people who I said are ultra kiasu?
As far as those people are concerned, I maintain they are still ultra kiasu despite those points of yours.
Everybody pays tax, my friend. And despite some claiming that the Chinese pay the most tax, I have seen figures said to have come from the Ministry of Finance/ Inland Revenue that they pay ony 30%, it's the GLCs that pay the most, at 40%, and the Malays plus others including foreigners pay 30%.
And I haven't touched the matter of "tax evasion" as well as deliberate "tax avoidance".
"corruption, abuse of power, funds missing, close tenders, etc" exist everywhere in the world, compadre. I'm not condoning it. The Government has been tackling it beginning with cutting out money politics in UMNO (which also exists in MCA and the ultra kiasu party DAP is also not free from corruption), the arrest of Ling Liong Sik, Immigration and Customs buggers, etc. I know it is not enough, but attempts have been made.
If for those you are saying the Government is also ultra kiasu, I disagree - unless you explain the meaning of ultra kiasu being different from extreme selfishness, don't want to be left out, don't want to lose out.
Tak habis-habis lagi penggunaan istilah ULTRA KIASU!
Islam adalah agama dakwah. Dakwah dengan hikmah. Harapan Malaysia pada masa depan tidap boleh terletak pada orang Melayu! Kerana orang Melayu telah terbukti kelemahannya: korupsi, malas, boros, tidak cekap, mabuk betina.....kecuali Melayu yang benar-benar pegang kepada ajaran Islam!
Masa depan Malaysia terletak pada muslim sejati, samada muslim Melayu, Cina, India, Arab atau orang putih. Muslim Melayu UMNO saja tak boleh harap!
Ada wakil Cina muslim bermati-matian nak pertahankan Melayu UMNO buat apa?
Ramai Melayu sendiri telah insaf, sebab itu mereka tinggalkan UMNO untuk menyertai PAS dan PKR!
Sepatutnya wakil Cina muslim mempelapori perjuangan multi-etnik dan nilai-nilai universal serta menolak fahaman sempit perkauman. Tetapi wakil Cina muslim pula nak berjinak-jinak dengan UMNO! Hairan sungguh!
Mengarut lah kamu dengan kata kata "Harapan Malaysia pada masa depan tidap boleh terletak pada orang Melayu". Kamu Melayu pengkhianat bangsa siapa mahu peduli.
Sebantal dengan kafir ultra kiasu DAP tak sedarkan depa bukan saja tarik bantal kamu tapi juga kain kamu masa kamu tidur. Kamu semua memang selalu tidur, tak sedarkan depa eksploitasikan bangsa Melayu, jadi lemah akibat tindakan kamu.
Apa mau harapkan PAS macam itu. Atau PKR yang sudah tunggang langgang banyak yang cabut lari termasuk bekas Menteri kesayangan Anwar - bernama Zaid.
Korang khayal dengan kata kata "mempelapori perjuangan multi-etnik dan nilai-nilai universal serta menolak fahaman sempit perkauman", kononnya. Tak sedarkan rakan sebantal korang, DAP, yang fahaman amat sempit dan perkauman yang tidak terhingga. Kau tak nampak atau tak faham ke apa makna sepandok depa Malaysian Malaysia kononnya. Yang cuba mengikis hak dan kepentingan Melayu dengan tak akui Kedudukan Istimewa Melayu.
Oh ya, korang tak pedulikan itu asalkan dapat mencium Putrajaya kononnya. Tak sedarkan Lim Kit Siang calon TPM, korang tak ada masuk dalam buku Anwar dan Kit Siang pun. Depa tak ada sebut PAS dapat apa jawatan pun kalau dapat kePutrajaya. Kesian, kesian, jenis korang ni.
Tambahan:
Kalau kamu Anon 2:47 PM adalah bukan Melayu menyamar atau memberi bayangan di komen kamu sebagai Melayu, maka kamu ultra kiasu yang teramat sangat. Jenis kongsi gelap, pengganas dan gengster. Perlu diheret ditepi pantai dan disula. Atau disumbat ke penjara selama lamanya.
“Oh ya, korang tak pedulikan itu asalkan dapat mencium Putrajaya kononnya. Tak sedarkan Lim Kit Siang calon TPM, korang tak ada masuk dalam buku Anwar dan Kit Siang pun. Depa tak ada sebut PAS dapat apa jawatan pun kalau dapat kePutrajaya. Kesian, kesian, jenis korang ni.”
Melayu macam inilah yang membuatkan Melayu cerdik jadi bodoh!
Yang rajin jadi malas!
Yang warak jadi sekular!
Yang jujur jadi tamak!
Yang bersih jadi korap!
Pasal apa? Pasal berkawan dengan MCA. Tengok Tun Ling Leong Sik, Tan Kong Chui, Eric Chia,
Dr. Chu Sui Lek yg mengaku diri dalam video seks tidak kena apa-apa oleh polis yg 'berbangsa' Melayu, tapi Anwar yg Melayu tulin yg memperjuangkan nilai Islam cuba disabitkan kesalahan vedio seks! Ini semua kejahatan UMNO yang direstui oleh itu wakil Cina muslim!
Tak perlu jawab, sebenarnya.
Hanya nak ketawakan sikit perenggan ke 2 dia, hahaha. Lucu.
TK lah kasi saya tea-time entertainment.
I find myself in strange territory listening to people like Ridhuan Tee or Reezal Merican, or Rahim Azeez speak for the Malays.
I would have thought, Malays are better off if THESE people speak on behalf of MACMA (Malaysian Chinese Muslim Association) or KIMMA (Kongres India Muslim Malaysia, OR Malaysian Indian Muslim Congress).
How can we force ourselves to suffer fools by allowing ourselves to consume the hate spewing writings ofsome bloggers whose Malay-ness are questionable?
Why isn't the peddler of rancid-curry speaking on behalf and FOR MACMA and KIMMA members?
Jadi jadi lah kita orang Melayu kena tipu.
I think Malays have got enough talented people to speak for ourselves.
Then we have those who pretend they speak for UMNO but are themselves NOT UMNO members.
The REAL UMNO man WOULDN'T speak of an imagined clash of Christians and Muslims or spun the story about Christians taking over this country.
Does a Malay cease to be a Malay if he is not an UMNO member?
Being UMNO is NOT an absolute requirement to fight for a Malay cause.
Those Malays in power have not actually helped other Malays.
So if UMNO insists that UMNO is Malay and Malay is UMNO, then by extension, Malays in power do not help the rest of Malays will also mean, UMNO in power does not help the rest of the Malays.
UMNO people must be realistic on this. One doesn't stop becoming Malay if one dismisses UMNO. People are already doing that if you still don't realize it.
Yet the leadership is hyping themselves, aided by a pliant audio visual and print media into believing all is well.
Ignorance is really bliss.
I on the other hand find people who dislike RT speaking for the Malays when they themselves can't as unacceptable and need being told off in similar fashion.
Particularly when fellows like this one who sounds non-Malay by saying Malays would be "better off if THESE people speak on behalf of MACMA (Malaysian Chinese Muslim Association) .."
He is himself a suffering fool, consumed by his hate spewing writing against some bloggers who want to help protect the rights and promote the interests of the Malays.
He knows not the definition of a Malay under the Constitution.
It's fine by me if this presumably peddler of pork speaking on behalf of the Chinese. But jadi jadi lah kita orang Melayu kena tipu by the ultra kiasus like DAP and their cohorts.
I agree that Malays have got enough talented people to speak for ourselves. But no harm for any others to speak for the Malays. Only a non like this bloke finds it unacceptable. He can eat his heart out as far I am concerned.
I'm not UMNO and don't have to always speak for UMNO and don't pretend that I dislike PAS and PKR for dividing the Malays. And anybody in between who exploits the Malays being a weak lot now. Most of all I abhor the pengkhianat Melayu and this bloke might be one.
But this bloke could be a Christian non who now appears to speak for the Christians disliking Malays who "spun the story about Christians taking over this country", says he.
Is a Malay really Malay if he appears to be a pengkhianat bangsa like this one? If this bloke is a Malay, that is.
Being PAS or PKR is OK but NOT when sleeping with the Malay-hating and Malay rights eroding DAP. They absolutely do not speak for a Malay cause that way. And they have not beeen speaking for the Malay cause, anyway.
Those Malays allowing themselves to be used by DAP have not and will not ever help other Malays.
So if PAS and PKR insist that they are fighting for the Malay cause by sleeping with the DAP, that is absolutely untrue and there should not be any extension of the support given them by Malays in the past. They should never be given power because they are helping the interests of the ultra kiasus and that does not help the rest of the Malays.
PAS and PKR people must be realistic on this. One stops being Malay when helping the chauvinistic, racist and subversive DAP cause whose so-called Malaysian Malaysia subverts the Special Position of the Malays and the Bumiputeras of Sabah and Sarawak. True, you are already doing that if you still don't realize it.
Yet the PAS and PKR members are hyping themselves, not realizing that the Sodomy I and II trials and the pliant audio visual and print media show that all is not well with with PR.
Ignorance of the implications of sleeping with Malay-hating DAP is not bliss. It's simply completely and utterly unfortunate and extremely regrettable.
How do you like this counter comment?
It has nothing to do with dislike.
Perhaps Thomas Lee Seng Hock in MySinchew.com provided the best explanation;
"The government should also initiate legal action against irresponsible writers, like the controversial Mingguan Malaysia columnist Dr Mohd Ridhuan Tee Abdullah who provokes the non-Malays with his weekly diatribe against them, saying that minorities who cannot respect the special position of Islam and the Malays should return to their "homeland", which he means China and India."
Ridhuan Tee is indeed known for writing crazy things, perhaps hired to do so, perhaps not.
Most of what he wrote easily convinces you that he was from another planet, but there is no point if he is penalised for what he wrote.
Penalising him will only force him to take his views underground and give him validation and that in turn will give him more support.
Anyway, we have no right to silence someone merely because our feelings are hurt. We must sit down and debate it out till the cows come home and then let "others" decide whose idea they favour. The favourable idea gets the vote and then we work on making it a reality.
There is no other civil way to deal with racism ala Ridhuan Tee, if we don’t provide good counsels as remedies to his evil counsels.
It is easy to let our emotions run unrestrained and say "Use the Sedition Act on him!" or "Use the ISA on him!"; that is a coward’s way of dealing with the problem.
As long as Acts like the ISA and Sedition exists, till then will Malaysians continue to be shackled, repressed and un-Merdeka.
As long as Acts like this exist and can be used on citizens, then we are not free people. In time, one day, it might also be used against anyone.
There are no shortcuts here ultimately - just a lot of patience, common sense and reason.
Anon 1:39 AM.
Thomas Lee Seng Hock has also been writing pro-Chinese and pro-Christian views. If the government initiate legal action against what he calls “irresponsible writers .. like columnist Dr Mohd Ridhuan Tee", Thomas’ past writings should also be scrutinized.
Dr Ridhuan has been trying to speak about loyalty to this country and exhorting the Malays/ Muslims to higher social, moral and economic values. Do read the many comments of appreciation written in this blog in the past.
This 1:39 AM writer is himself irresponsible when saying “Ridhuan Tee is indeed known for writing crazy things, perhaps hired to do so ..”. Suggesting Dr Ridhuan is paid – presumably by UMNO – is nonsensical. The man gets paid no more than like other columnists who contribute to various newspapers – one PhD law lecturer of UM also contributes columns to one other newspaper.
This 1:39 AM writer is off-planet when he says Dr Ridhuan “was from another planet”, but is in-planet when he said “there is no point if he is penalised for what he wrote”.
No such thing as “take his views underground and give him .. more support”. His supporters are all out in the open here, like bloggers/ commenters using all sorts of blogging names or anon comments in other blogs as well.
He is being responsible in saying “we have no right to silence someone merely because our feelings are hurt. We must sit down and debate it out till the cows come home and then let "others" decide whose idea they favour”.
Add one more: sit down, read the Constitution fully, ask yourself if you accept and respect it fully, including all the sensitive aspects that are covered by the Sedition Act. If you do, you are welcome as a fellow Malaysian. Otherwise, you may be ultrakiasu (can people not use this word? If not pls explain why, esplly when you have used the word “crazy”, “evil councils” etc on Dr Ridhuan), and we have problems like with the ultrakiasu DAP members and supporters.
I'll use your words in saying there is no other civil way to deal with racism ala DAP, if we don’t provide good counsels as remedies to their evil words and deeds. Are you not racist yourself for accusing others being racist unjustifiably?
In fact, per the dictionary, the word racism should only be used when there is antagonism towards another race. Like those flogging the so-called Malaysian Malaysia slogan that wants to erode the Special Position of the Malays and the Bumiputeras of Sabah and Sarawak by wanting equality without acknowledging that Special Position.
I fully support the Sedition Act and the ISA. You should visit the Guantanamo Bay Detention Centre in the USA and see that even the so-called “most liberal country in the world” also practices detention without trial even right to this day – at the last count recently, there were about 200 detainees still there.
You talk about “Malaysians continue to be shackled, repressed and un-Merdeka” – the Guantanamo Bay detainees are in fact still really in shackles, unlike our ISA detainees in Kamunting Detention Centre, free to move about within the premises.
You should also be aware that another of the so-called “most liberal country in the world”, the UK, has its PM recently say “multi-culturalism is dead”. Echoed by the German Chancellor and 2 other EU leaders. Freedom has its limits, with freedom there is responsibility.
When people talk about unity and single-stream education through the Satu Sekolah Untuk Semua or SSS, it should not be countered by talk about “multi-nations within a nation” nonsense like the Dong Zong leader did. Wanting Mandarin at par with the BM as the National Language of the country, etc. There must be just one Malaysian community with one Kiblat or direction for loyalty, not otherwise. The loyalty of all Malaysians must be to Malaysia and no other.
Agreed there are no shortcuts here, but the relevant laws must be applied when people do not use common sense and reason as far as respecting and abiding by the Constitution of the country is concerned.
Malaysia race relations, in 50 years, shows that behind the façade of outward unity and peace, racism runs deep in this multi-ethnic 'melting pot'.
This is partly because ethnic boundaries are real in our society and almost every sphere of public life is linked to ethnicity in one way or another.
More than half the population does not trust each other.
A survey found that 42 percent do not consider themselves Malaysian first, 46 percent say ethnicity is important in voting, 55 percent blame politicians for racial problems and 70 percent would help their own ethnic group first.
Experts have been voicing concern that, increasingly, the communities were drifting apart and polarization of the races and a lack of social unity were on the rise.
They squarely blame the politicians and the country's race-based politics for the sharp rise in racism. The shocking findings have also prompted civil society to demand a ban on all race- based political parties.
According to lawyer politician A. Sivanesan, we should outlaw all Malaysian political parties that restricts membership on grounds of race, religion or sex. It should be written in the constitution that only multi-racial bodies be permitted.
Sivanesan also said that social problems affect all communities. Poverty, drug and crime are not specific to any one race. All races face the blight.
Sivanesan noted that the various races live peacefully but separately. It is already half a century after independence and we are further away from knowing each other!
In the survey, even Hari Raya Puasa was wrongly perceived as the Malay New Year by 32 per cent of Malays, 84 per cent of Chinese and 45 per cent of Indians -when the festival actually marks the culmination of Ramadan, the holy month of fasting.
Similarly, the Chinese New Year was thought to be a religious festival by 57 percent of Malays, 53 percent of Indians and a whopping 62 percent of Chinese respondents.
Why? Partly because the government officially practices a policy of positive discrimination that favours Malays over other races in many areas - from employment, education, scholarships and business to cheaper housing and assisted savings.
Therefore, we need to appeal to the Malays, Chinese and the Indians and the rest that we need to go beyond race-based politics. If you continue to harp and support this racial equation, you will never be able to overcome racial divisions.
Racism in Malaysia is too deeply entrenched in official policies and the socio-political system!
" Fahamkah kita apakah maksud universiti itu sebenarnya? Di luar negara, tidak ada universiti berasaskan etnik"
betul jugak. saya setuju hujahan ini, RT. tapi apa itu institut kemahiran MARA? apa itu sekolah sains berasrama penuh yang bumiputera melayu saja?
hey melayu celup, dont talk ccok la.
saya jugak setuju dengan kau buat apa nak kuasai bahasa malaysia. setakat faham cukup lah. tiada nilai komersial langsung melainkan tawar menawar dengan polis trafik dan KHDN.
agak pelik blogger blogger disini.
selalu cakap pasal melayu. pasal perpaduan melayu. tapi bila sendiri malas belajar dan dapat keputusan yang tidak memuaskan, nak salahkan kera-jaan pulak. nak salah bangsa lain pulak.
bahasa sendiri pun tidak mampu kuasai, nak salahkan puak lain.
inilah sikap orang melayu ala perkasa/umno sekarang.
malas tapi nak senang.
Anonymous 2:47 PM,
Tak boleh habis penggunaan istilah ULTRA KIASU. Selagi ada jenis ULTRA KIASU. Tak faham kenapa awak tak suka.
Saya bukan nak dakwah agama Islam. Saya nak dakwah perpaduan. Tak mahu yang ultra kiasu. Kalau tak, susah nak dapat perpaduan.
Awak cakap "Dakwah dengan hikmah". Pastu kata "Harapan Malaysia pada masa depan tidap boleh terletak pada orang Melayu!" Apa lah jenis awak ni! Apa makna hikmah awak? Cakap tak serupa bikin.
Awak Melayu ke? Cakap "Melayu .. korupsi, malas, boros, tidak cekap, mabuk betina....." Cina takda macam tu ke? Chua Soi Lek tak mabuk betina ke? Yang Ahli Parlimen bebas dulu PKR kata Lim Kit Siang ada gufreng seorang pekerja diDAP HQ tu tak mabuk betina ke?
Siapa "Melayu yang benar-benar pegang kepada ajaran Islam"? Awak sorang ke? Atau awak bukan Melayu tapi menghasut? Salah disisi Akta Hasutan, tau tak?
Cakap pulak "Muslim Melayu UMNO saja tak boleh harap!" Tak cakap pulak Muslim Melayu PAS atau PKR. Ini jenis yang selalu pakai exclamation mark (!) ni nampak macam kenal. Awak dulu pakai nama PENYOKONG DAP ke? Jika betul, kenapa sekarang malu nak keluar begitu?
Apa awak peduli "Ada wakil Cina muslim bermati-matian nak pertahankan Melayu UMNO"? Mind your own business lah.
Awak nak hasut lagi. Kata pulak "Ramai Melayu sendiri telah insaf .. tinggalkan UMNO untuk menyertai PAS dan PKR!" Takda bukti pulak tu.
Mengata pulak "wakil Cina muslim" sepatutnya "menolak fahaman sempit perkauman". Sebenarnya kata kata awak tu yang berupa fahaman perkauman sempit. Tak pasal pasal nak marah orang nak pertahankan Melayu.
Apa kau peduli "wakil Cina muslim pula nak berjinak-jinak dengan UMNO!" Apa "Hairan sungguh!" Aku tak hairan pun jenis kau ni. Orang panggil ULTRA KIASU. Pastu kau kata tak habis habis orang cakap pasal tu.
RT, stop being a bast*rd. stop making your future generations suffer and shame of having an ancestor who is a melayu celup and trying to be more malay than the malays, all for that 2 cents reward.
with all huha about your 'kiblat', just explain what is institut kemahiran MARA and other endless instituition mean for malays only?
nobody question this issue but why you need to mind other people's business?
you are an undisputed bast*rd!!! congrats!!!
hahaha, itu zebra belum mati lagi?
dah kena banned by blogger.com kot.
sampaikan kena pakai 'anonymous '.
muak hahaha.. bodoh punya zebra/pembangkang dap!
Anon 11.47 AM,
1. Who runs the Survey, pray tell. If it's Merdeka Centre, do you know if it's an independent org or beholden to the financiers. I read some said it has links with Anwar.
2. I agree that, "increasingly, the communities were drifting apart and polarization of the races and a lack of social unity were on the rise." But what are you going to do about that?
3. I haven't read about "civil society to demand a ban on all race- based political parties". But I'm interested if it can be done.
4. Btw, who is "lawyer politician A. Sivanesan"? What I know is that the Constitution cannot be changed willy nally. Would any politician want to take administrative action to banning race-based political parties?
Haha, the exclamation mark you use may be telling on you! Is Sivanesan DAP? Are you saying DAP is not race-based in reality?
You seem to be so when you accuse the government "officially practices a policy of positive discrimination that favours Malays over other races in many areas .."
Then I got to feel that this is a DAP propaganda hogwash. When you allege "Racism in Malaysia is too deeply entrenched in official policies and the socio-political system!", do think about the Special Position of the Malays and the Bumiputeras of Sarawak and Sabah and that the nons got citizenship right which they didn't have for about 80 years under the British before Merdeka.
Try to exclude the exclamation marks as they are telling on you. Also the rude boy appearing at about the same time, hahaha. I bet you if the name PENYOKONG DAP comes out, PEMBANGKANG DAP would come out to counter his comments as always.
The government which had been ruling for more than 50 years is actually a menace to his own people. Why? You can see the effects of their foolishness when the ringgit has halved its value overnight and the economy goes kaput.
Single handedly they have caused hardship to millions of their own people.
They built useless mega projects at tremendous cost to the country. The telecoms tower in Kuala Lumpur and the highest building in the world show how stupid they are. If you need high ground for telecoms
antennae, a nearby mountain is there for free. This tower has no
purpose from the ground up to 300 metres. The satelites are already there and this tower is totally unneccesary.
A fool and his money are soon parted. The only problem is that they are the fools and the money belongs to Malaysians. They make certain percentage in every project, they have real estate in Japan and billions of shares corruptly acquired.
They are worth billion US$. Where do they get this money? Of course, corruptions. They are known as the
Marcos of Malaysia, having enriched themselves to the tune of billions.
A thief is crying thief and hopes people look the other way. Who dares to say anything when the chief is caught with his hands in the candy jar?
Everone knows that wisdom is not the monopoly of the West. So is foolishness.
They are really foolish than most people would believe. Billions
are used to build two high rise Petronas buildings that benefit
nobody. It now stand tall, a symbol of stupidity and irresponsibility.
How can a Moron make so much money. By allowing short selling and borrowing millions of shares from the banks , the fund managers made millions out of the inexperience and poor regulations.
They lose all Malaysians money, therefore they are the Morons. Now they knew too late and start crying over spill milk.
In Australia they are known as the recalcitrant ego maniac; in UK the
corrupt bastard because of their stupidity purchase of the movie studio and the 290 million ringgit Lotus racing car plant and the shady Pergau dam loans from the UK. They are useless to us and they still want to buy them.
What about buying British reject submarines through their agent, of course. The agent/ broker is designed to make millions out of Malaysian government.
The purchase of our battleships is at least 50% more than others are paying.
The purchase of 9 hospitals from UK lock, stock and barrel does not support the local architects
or the industry and the British send them obsolete medical equipment.
The design is atrocious, one end to the other is half a kilometer and
there is no CT-scan, which was an absolute necessity.
In Malaysia they are spending millions to lure tourists and still they talk rubbish scaring every foreigner away.
While I agree the West does not have the monopoly to wisdom, their
actions are not wise either.
Their EAEC has totally no support
even in Asean. Their South-South dialogue mets with the same fate and what is this I heard of the Bridge from Malaysia to Indonesia covering 20 miles across International shipping lanes? How crazy can one get?
Even the Japanese don’t have the money. This world’s of stupidity comes from UMNO and BN.
Still want to vote these stupidity and foolishness?
Haha, kena chelen nampaknya aku. Selalunya aku tak pedulikan budak kecik cakap kurang ajar disini, melainkan sekali sekala aku sekel kepala dia sikit.
Sebenarnya, aku jarang keluar, kurang sikit nampak terpampang nama aku menemplak menempeleng DAP. Tapi dah kena chelen, aku akan keluar selalu lepas ni.
Hah, dah nampak satu komen yang nyata pendirian DAP, aku akan tempelak sekejap lagi. Bersedialah! (haha, aku pun nak ikut cara PENYOKONG DAP selalu pakai exclamation mark !)
The political repercussions on the citizenry to challenge official dictates became too fearsome to contemplate.
The BN government instilled the collective fear that walls have ears, and the collective view that the citizen's sole right is to elect the BN to power, that he stands to lose his self-respect in society if he should ask too many intrusive questions or, indeed, if he should vote those it does not like to Parliament or, God forbid, elect an opposition to power in a state.
Politics in Malaysia is still dominated by BN and Umno, even if they recede into themselves and prone to regard those who elected them as enemies.
They will not explain, they will not defend, they will not assuage, they will use the whip to keep in line but are helpless when the revolts continue unabated.
The BN and Umno can dominate politics only with threats and undemocratic methods. And every unfair, illegal or unlawful action it takes challenged and resisted.
Scapegoats are sought, redress is promised, threats are made, but in the end, it is pushed under the carpet. And hope no one else would raise it again. Or until the next time any perfidy gets into the public eye.
Ini Anon 1.10 PM sama orangnya dengan budak kecik cakap kotor kurang ajar tu. Selalu keluar atas dua tiga nama pada masa yang lebih kurang sama. Lantak lah dia, asalkan aku boleh bidas yang bunyi macam PENYOKONG DAP.
He doesn’t know about economics but wants to hit the Government for “the ringgit has halved its value overnight and the economy goes kaput”. Loose talk about supposedly “Single handedly they have caused hardship to millions of their own people”. Sigh!
He has no perspective about development. Tries to blame the Telecoms Tower in Kuala Lumpur and the highest building in the world. He hasn’t a clue about the US building the tallest structure called the Empire State Building and the Twin Towers in New York. Or Shanghai and Taiwan been competing for the same. Ultra kiasu mentality is like that.
A fool as he, he tries to find each and every thing to blame the Government. Except the kilang kabut PR Government in Selangor which includes DAP goons like door- banging Ronnie Liu. The only problem is that they are the gangster kind and spend the RM500,000 per Exco allowance in no time. The MACC investigated, TBH died and they blamed MACC even before the cause of death is known until now.
This bloke will rattle on worse than a rattle snake. Accuse everybody of corruption except DAP. Yet Ronnie Liu used his letterhead for influencing tenders in Selangor. Ean Yong “determined tender prices” as the Chinese businessman testified at the TBH C.O.Inquiry. And Lim Guan Eng launched a multi-billion Ringgit Penang Municipality project not on open tender basis.
But I’ll behave responsibly in not accusing Lim Gaung Eng corrupt there. I’ll leave it to readers to think about the scores of levels and places where corruption can happen in such a huge project carried out that way. The DAP thugs and gangsters will see to it that no one "sees, hears or tells" about the millions being corrupted in the process.
Loose canon, shooting from the hip, this son of a gun may be. Endlessly calling people fools except himself. Can’t even see the benefits of building the Petronas Towers. He’s simply called Ultra Kiasu. Where he does not benefit directly, his mother, father, brother and sisters don’t get the Ringgits, he’ll say all sorts of things.
Making all kinds of accusations without any proofs, facts or data. Who, how, when and where. Talk about “Australia .. UK .. movie studio, 290 million ringgit Lotus racing car plant and the shady Pergau dam loans”. What the hell is he talkin’ about? And about “buying British reject submarines through their agent .. purchase of 9 hospitals from UK lock, stock and barrel”.
Yet if he provides the proofs, I would be the first one to support him. Even volunteer taking the proofs (must be of the nature of “evidence” that can stand in court) to the MACC if he is “shy” to do it.
This loose gun keeps on rambling. But enough of my undressing him in public for the no proof, names, particulars or even details of when, where and how. A lot is of course DAP hogwash. Just see his last bit of desperado – “Still want to vote these stupidity and foolishness?” What a shame. So stupid, so bland, so distasteful kind of sick DAP propaganda.
In an interview with The Sun, Dr. Shad Saleem Faruqi, a professor of law claimed that the Federal Constitution of Malaysia has been amended more than 600 times!(ref : Legal Research Board (Edts), Federal Constitution, Petaling Jaya, International Law Book Services, 2007, pg. 21) That’s 600 times in 50 years. Compare this with the United States Constitution which has been amended only 27 times in the 220 years it has existed.
How is this so? It would be quite bold, in fact it would be a joke to suggest that Malaysia has a more advanced democracy than the United States of America. The real answer is quite simple, of the 40 times the Federal Constitution of Malaysia has been amended, several amendments were done together but not declared as individual amendments.
Conversely, even the smallest change in a single clause in the United States Constitution is considered as one amendment, so why have there been so few amendments to the United States Constitution and so many in the Federal Constitution of Malaysia?
The answer to this question is related to the fact that Malaysia has a very backward democratic process, in other words, it is very easy for the ruling party to pass whatever laws and whatever amendments they wish to because they have consistently held two-thirds majority in the Parliament for the past fifty years.
According to Dr. Shad, between 1991 and 1995, 80% of Bills presented in Parliament were passed without any debate. The party that holds two-thirds majority in Parliament is the de-facto ruling party, Barisan Nasional (BN).
This is not the case in the United States of America where there have been many occasions when the majority of lawmakers were from opposition parties, so there is a lot of debate before a Bill is passed and whether or not it is passed is irrespective of the interests of the executive branch of government.
I like this statement by Anon 2.05 PM –
“those it does not like to Parliament or, God forbid, elect an opposition to power in a state”.
I simply like to repeat it –
“those it does not like to Parliament or, God forbid, elect an opposition to power in a state”.
Hahaha. (I’ve learnt about exploiting from the ultra kiasu DAP here, hahaha).
Hah, Anon 2:40 PM is exploiting what Dr Shad Faruqi said.
Don't know the context Dr Shad was making the statement in.
Hello, Dr Shad, you'll be made famous by this fellow exploiting what you said.
Malaysians already saying no to the RM5-billion 100-storey Mega Tower proposed by PM Najib in the 2011 budget. Malaysia needs better education, better health care, better public transportation, safer neighbourhood, cleaner water, but not taller building.
Tall towers do not symbolise progress.
The ruling regime is suffering from a complex called idiotic pride; trumpeting grandioseness on the outside but trampling democracy inside.
This goes to the ultra-modernisation of our national defense system itself. We didn't even need to 'modernise the armed forces' – the enemy is inside the country, amongst the corrupt politicians and robber barons, not outside of us amongst the internally-problematic ASEAN nations themselves.
We need to look at our immediate needs and prioritise as a nation that is losing its sense of direction guided by a regime that is intoxicated with power derived from the orchestration of the archaic strategy of divide and rule using race as a tool.
It appears that the link between the executive and legislative branches of Malaysian government is not a healthy relationship.
The executive branch of government has become too powerful, or rather, too arrogant because of their ability to pass or reject any law.
Members of Parliament (MPs) from the BN who are not enthusiastic about Bills proposed by the ruling party are suppressed or sometimes punished for their lack of cooperation, or rather, lack of submission by what is known as the Whip.
BN MPs are not allowed to represent their constituency but are instead forced to submit to the wishes of BN leaders, because the Prime Minister is the leader of the party holing majority seats in Parliament, which unfortunately for us is BN.
An MP who has no allegiance to any party, an independent candidate seems to be the perfect answer and the leaders of BN are well aware of this fact.
There are several worst case scenarios to consider in the event that this trend of backward democracy continues.
The most important is that the legislative branch of government could end up destroying the constitution.
There’s not much to stop them from destroying it because they’ve already altered it so much that it’s a completely different document, a watered down version of the original.
If the Federal Constitution of Malaysia was a person, her parents would not recognize her today because she has changed so much since she was born. Her parents left her with guardians who abused her and forced her to change into a different person.
It is sad to think that the Federal Constitution of Malaysia has been amended, it has been raped, over 600 times.
It is not imperative that those responsible are punished, but their wrongs must be made right before everyone loses faith in democracy.
Another loose gun at 2:59 PM.
Look at him say "Tall towers do not symbolise progress". And he uses the word "symbolise"!
Such words as "suffering from a complex called idiotic pride; trumpeting grandioseness on the outside but trampling democracy inside". No attempt to justify what he says at all. No facts, data and details. Only his personal opinions. What a pity!
The same about "the ultra-modernisation of our national defense system itself". Such a shame that this fellow with good written English writes no meat except kacang putih. I'd expect him to put some substance, facts, data and arguments. Alas, only a diatribe. Sad fellow. Such a waste.
Me? I'm here only for the bangkang.
From the ancient architectures of symbolic power such as the pyramids of Gizeh, the temples of the Incas and the Mayans, the Hanging Gardens of Babylon, the Great Wall of China, the Collosus of Rhodes, and many more – all these are about glorifying tyrants and sacrificing the masses.
Millions died unknown in history whilst names such as Ramses, Shah Jehan, Shih Huang-Ti, and Nebuchadnezzar are remembered for their fame or infamy.
In the history of postmodern civilisations, the erecting of the tallest structures has become a race for idiotic pride and madness. The Eiffel Tower, the Empire State building, the Sears Tower, and the Petronas Twin Towers, Xujjahui in China, International Commerce Centre in Hong Kong, Shanghai World Financial Centre, Taipei 101, Burj Khalifa, and the proposed Lotte World II – all these are symbols of idiotic pride of the both the capitalist and socialist worlds.
By the way, do you know that the language we write affect our personality / persona?
Another tin kosong at 3.08 PM. Theory, theory, theory. Didn't hear the Professor says theory often differs from practice. Cakap tak serupa bikin, like the DAP.
Again another loose statement - "the Federal Constitution of Malaysia has been amended, it has been raped, over 600 times." Not an iota of an attempt to explain how at least in one instance. Merely quote Dr Shad Faruqi up there.
Like that, I can also quote so many other people, don't care in or out of context, just to abuse his statements. But don't want to waste my time on the fler lah. Just wanna show his unreasonableness (note: have not used the word stupid or fool like one fler up there), despite him appearing educated.
Hahaha Anon 3:27 PM trying to be smart, asking "do you know that the language we write affect our personality / persona?"
It's not the language, brada. It's the substance, the thinking, the facts, data, details and the kind of arguments you put out, if you are putting out non-mainstream views.
Me? I'm OK. Because I put out mainstream views.
What views are mainstream, you might ask - views that are based on the Constitution of the country, Mamat.
Susah sgt ke nak gantikan sekolah jenis kebangsaan kepada sekolah kebangsaan ?
Kena tunggu ada PM yang tegas dan berani. Melayu berpecah dek PAS Nik Aziz dan PKR Anwar sebantal dengan DAP Lim Kit Siang, PM sekarang mengejar undi Cina sesangat tak berani nak buat sekolah satu aliran takut tak dapat undi diorang.
Remember that these ultra-kiasu people who are here trying to divert our attention to something else.
Let us back to the main topic - the national patriotisme, the national language and about school based on race.
Pembangkang-DAP and the gang, don't mind those brainless kids who always play the "dive and divert" style. All of those nonsense garbage they spout won't give us headache no? Let them with their world.
These brainless kids are making use of Goebbles words ; "lies can be truth by telling it many times".
For a good example of nowadays human with a brain of an ape, such as LimKitSiang, Michael Chick and the likes.
All they do is blurting garbage out of their brain, twisting facts and divert.
It is time for "multiculturisme is dead".
saya tidaklah hairan kalau pihak ultra kiasu menyokong sekolah vernacular. Tetapi apalah daya kita kalau Perdana Menteri Najib sendiri kerapkali dalam kenyataannya sangat berbangga kerana Malaysia adalah satu-satunya negara di dunia membenarkan sekolah mengikut kaum.
wtf :), with the pro RT people here, multi culturalism is dead in malaysia. and why bother about bahasa ' malaysia '?
a language to communicate with the traffic police and KHDN.
nobody gives a damn whether you fail or pass your BM.
better worry about how much you can ' korek korek korek ' from national coffers.
semua pun mahu korek. tapi own children sent to orphanage. and still have the guts to collect the donations meant for the kids.
dignity is also dead in the umno- perkasa society. disgusting!
Ginosaji,
Agreed, bro. Budak kecik tu selalunya I bo layan. Cuma sekali sekala nak sekel kepala dia sikit.
But the one sounding pandai, quoting Professor etc, I want to show readers he actually tak pandai. Make wild accusations, give personal opinions only, no facts, data or details. I think now readers already see how empty his statements are, how futile and laughable his efforts have been.
Kalau depa masuk lagi, nak buat macam tu jugak. Will not allow what they say go unchallenged. Otherwise puak depa tepuk tangan, naik tocang.
really hats off to the people who can send their children to orphange.
satu lagi sumbangan dan projek kerajaan barisan nasional. :)
these people are so proud to be beggars. or born without brain.
no need to have a lorry load of children if cant afford to bring up them.
dont be a nuisance and burden to the taxpayers, idiots!!!!
Alias,
Daya kita: Teruskan cakap apa saja minta sekolah satu aliran. Sebutkan mengapa perlu walau pun sudah diulang berkali kali.
Kita rayu dan gesa dia. Kemudian, kita rayu dan gesa Majlis Tertinggi UMNO. Lepas tu kita rayu dan gesa Ahli Ahli Jawatan Kuasa Bahagian dan Cawangan UMNO. Penghabis sekali, kita rayu dan gesa Ahli Biasa UMNO.
Najib kena buat punya. Dia dah kata dalam blog 1Malaysianya bahawa "Sistem sekolah satu aliran akan dilaksanakan apabila rakyat mahukannya". Cuma tak sebutkan bila atau macam mana nak tentukan rakyat mahukannya sekarang atau tidak. Pihak Kempen SSS (Satu Sekolah Untuk Semua) sudah cadangkan cara pungutan suara "referendum" sebagai cara yang paling baik dan selamat baginya.
Marilah kita terus laungkan dari masa kemasa.
jadi kenapa jaga tepi kain orang when you cant even afford to feed your own children?
sampaikan hantar them to orphanage or madrasah?
anak sendiri pun tak mampu biayai dan jaga, kanapa nak bimbang tentang paras bahasa malaysia orang lain?
tapi bila berlakunya bencana seperti tanah runtuh, ibubapa2 mangsa2 tersebut keluar berpusu-pusu keluar minta sedekah dan sumbangan orang ramai. tak malu kah? rupa rupanya mangsa mangsa tanah runtuh itu bukan anak yatim, tapi dihantar ke sana sebab ibubapa tidak ingin membela mereka!
ibubapa sebegini lebih teruk dari binatang!
Hairan juga, tidak nampak ada blogger blogger disini yang hentam orang2 macam ni. mungkin itu budaya kau orang disini :) suka jaga tepi kain orang :)
gajah didepan tak nampak, kuman diseberang dicari!
useless generation.
Song beNGONG,
Rumah anak yatim dan madrasah ok?U know what is madrasah?STFU and go die with all of your family!ahaahaaaahaa
hahaha, siapa yang bengong :)
hahaha.. pergi la argue your article 151, 152, 153 and so on.
nobody gives a damn.
tapi aku suka beri sedekah... terutama sekali kepada generasi sedekah perkasa / umno.
syiok, bayar sedekah rm1, dapat untung rm5.
Sdr Alias
Saya tidak tahu kenyataannya yang mana, bila, dimana dan sepertinya, yang Sdr katakan Najib "sangat berbangga kerana Malaysia adalah satu-satunya negara di dunia membenarkan sekolah mengikut kaum".
Saya tidak pernah terbaca begitu. Kalau dia benar ada kata begitu, dia sudah melebehi apa yang boleh rakyat umum terima. Dia sudah ketinggalan zaman dan UMNO perlu tinggalkan dia. Sebab, macam Ginosaji kata diatas, diEropah pun mereka dah kata "multiculturalism is dead".
song bodoh. dh name pun umah anak2 yatim n madrasah...bukan umah anak2 yatim je..klu dh bodoh psl hal2 org melayu jgn la bg statement..klu x peduli psl perlembagaan, ape lagi...pg la blk china.
Kalau ade yang masih rase DAP tu x ultrakiasu, bc komen2 song...sbb die adalah contoh terbaik menilai majoriti cina ultra-kiasu di Malaysia.
Bagus, teruskan bg statement2 bangang...lagi la aku benci kat DAP..
:)
Apa pulak hal si song ni. Mesti lupa makan ubat, tiba2 meroyan mengarut dan menyalak pasal anak yatim. Baghal ke ape?
Lari tajuk dah. Dah tak dapat lawan macam tu la cara orang2 macam ni ubah topik. Budak2 sungguh.
YA multiculturisme is dead. Dead for shameless pigs like you.
Multiculture is available only to those who abide by the law and constitution.
Easy equation. You stay here, follow the rules. If not, get the fuck out.
This applies to everyone of us. Easy right? So don't complain when the words "balik China" were shouted. It meant perfectly for you and your kind, song.
So, what's the word? Come on lame ass, I'm bored with your same ol' "sedekah" thing. Don't you have anything exciting to say?
Enlighten me.
@song
Ehem last but not least. Untuk song yang otak terlebih nutrien, ni aku nak cakap sikit.
Anak yatim bermaksud anak yang kehilangan ibu atau bapa KANDUNG. Contoh disertakan kerana song ni otak "terlebih" nutrien(aku taknak dia salah faham), Rahmat telah kehilangan emak, dan setahun selepas itu bapanya menikah baru. Walaupun Rahmat dapat pengganti ibu kandung tetapi status Rahmat adalah anak yatim.
Ada faham? Sebelum cakap fikir banyak2, selidik fakta dulu. Jangan jadi sampah. Kau ckp mcm kau pandai tapi bodoh nak mampos. Buat orang lain penat je kena jelaskan.
And one more thing. Mana kau tau yg minta bantuan tu emak/bapa anak2 yatim tu? Takde ke terfikir dalam kepala otak kau yg orang2 tu mungkin bapa/emak saudara mereka?
Kalau kau tak puas ati apsal hantar situ, kenapa cepat sangat buat kesimpulan?
Song hai Song.... kau ni sampah sangat la. Bosan.
Saya tau tak lama lagi pagi ni RT akan keluar pos baru. Tapi saya nak tulis ini for the record di pos ini juga.
RT kata "Bagi mereka agenda nasional tidak penting, yang penting agenda bangsa."
Agenda bangsa sendiri satu hal. Tapi cuba merosakkan agenda bangsa lain tak boleh dibiarkan.
Resolusi seminar MCA mahukan sasaran ekuiti Bumiputera dihapuskan tidak boleh didiamkan sama sekali. Ada yang telah reaksi mahukan hak kerakyatan mereka juga dihapuskan.
MCA Chua dan Wee jangan sekali kali lagi buat demikian. Disumpah Melayu tidak habis habisan.
Bukan DAP saja ultra kiasu. Mereka diMCA pun sudah mula begitu.
Cina kaum yang paling kaya, memenuhi kebanyakan jawatan professional dinegara ini. MCA Chuah dan Wee sibuk serta heboh dengan isu scholarship. Dah dikasi scholarship belajar tempatan. Mahukan scholarship belajar luar ngeri pulak. Selfish ultra kiasu tak habis habis.
Pada hal diorang dah dikasi buat universiti sendiri. Beribu jutawan Cina sanggup keluar duit sumbangan untuk kemudahan universiti dan scholarship budak Cina. Begitu banyak derma dapat hingga UTAR tahun lalu tak mahu terima RM30 juta dari seorang jutawan Cina. Sekarang nak scholarship lagi. Nak scholarship luar negeri pulak. Apa ni?
Ultra kiasu teramat sangat. Melampau.
Najib lah PM yang mula mula beri scholarship kapada budak Cina. Dia tak ambik kira perasaan orang Melayu. Melayu yang ketinggalan jauh dibelakang sebab dasar pemerintahan British kolonial dan keadaan bangsa Melayu dizaman dulu. Saya dan kawan kawan dah menyampah dengan Najib.
Bila MCA Chua hebohkan isu biasiswa/ scholarship luar negeri, ada Najib kata dia tak pernah janjikan scholarship luar negeri kapada budak Cina. Ooi Abang Jib, bukan saja scholarship luar negeri, scholarship tempatan pun sudah salah anda janjikan.
Bukan kah diorang sudah kaya raya, sudah penuh dijawatan professional? Kalau asyik kasi, macam mana nak seimbangkan jumlah Melayu dalam bidang professional dengan jumlah Cina? Kan tak habis habis rasa iri hati, cemburu dsbnya, sebab diorang yang terkaya dinegara ini dan dah bersepah dibidang professional.
Macam orang dah banyak kata, kenapa anda mahu melutut kapada diorang lagi? Diorang tak patut nak
rasa iri hati atas sebab sebab yang disebut diatas. Dan diorang patut dan perlu terima dan ikuti Perkara 153 Perlembagaan negara Kedudukan Istimewa Melayu.
Sedarlah kamu bahawa ultra kiasu hardcore walau macam mana pun tidak akan undi BN. Baca saja apa budak "song" dah cakap disini berkali kali. Sedarlah. Tolong.
Anda terus layan diorang ultra kiasu, beri scholarship dsbnya kapada kaum yang diketahui terkaya dan terbanyak dilapangan professional, Melayu pun lari dari mengundi anda. Perlu dengar diorang dah banyak kata: jangan yang dikejar tak dapat, yang dikendong keciciran.
Saya harap jangan Nazri pulak bagi macam macam lagi diperjumpaan dipejabatnya dengan wakil wakil MCA dll yang diberitakan akan berlaku minggu ini.
Abdullah ngah,
bukan umno/bn yang buat silap. yang buat silap mca/bn. sebab? cuba ko tengok sape yang mulakan dulu dalam banyak hal? umno ke? takde de... sume yang mintak itu ini parti ultra kiasu ni la...pelik sungguh ko ni. umno jugak yg ko persalahkan. tak nampak-nampak lagi ke?
SAYA RASA ADA SEORANG BUDAK CINA YANG RASA DIRI DIA SANGAT PANDAI DAN TERLALU HEBAT DALAM BLOG INI................ADAKAH DIA SEORANG PROFESOR? DOKTOR? INGIN TAHU JUGA STATUS DIA INI.MUNGKIN AHLI BAHASA......
Saya cadangkan kepada Song supaya dia menyanyi lagu Majulah Singapura dan duduk di sana.
Post a Comment